Out of all 18 winners because Eddie doesn't count... you first have to count the ones who qualify for the following
A: Didn't deserve to win
B: Rigged win
People who fall under this are: (Dick-Jordan-Rachel-Ian-Steve-Josh)
Very hard to determine whos the worst....
Rigged win?: Dick-Jordan-Rachel-Josh
Or just flat out bad winner - Ian-Steve
Eddie, Josh, Jordan, Rachel and Dick are the worst of the US winners because the game was different, or they fell ass-backwards into their win, or only won because of twists/rigging.
Personally, Josh is the worst.
Followed by Rachel due to all the rigging that occurred for her to win.
Followed by Steve, who was the best of the 2 finalists.
Andy was also not a LIKED winner, but IMO a good winner. Just played a VERY FLOATER type game and would probs be up there for me.