Based on the "Previously On..." segments from the show.
Episode 1: We didn't get much gameplay from this episode other than Josh/Marcellas targetting each other and Lisa winning HoH, so Lisa gets the point.
Episode 2: We saw Lisa as apart of some alliances forming, and we got her nominations, Lisa gets this point.
Episode 3: We saw Josh as the one kind of "calling the shots" to take Marcellas out, yet we hear from Gerry that he doesn't like how Josh is playing. I think I will give the point to Gerry for winning the first PoV.
Episode 4: Gerry upset his allies with his play to save Marcellas, and Lisa/Josh did not get their way. I'll give the point to Marcellas.
Episode 5: We got to hear that the six person alliance was getting divided and we heard that Amy was being told she was safe (without giving much credit to her), so I think I will give the point to Marcellas for winning HoH.
Episode 6: We got to hear that Josh was pushing for Gerry to go up on the block, but Marcellas put Josh up alongside Tonya which was probably the correct move, so Marcellas gets another point.
Episode 7: We saw Danielle win the veto and we saw Josh lobbying for the veto to be used on him, as well as lobbying for votes. I think I will give the point to Danielle.
Episode 8: I think I will give this point to Josh for surviving the block over Tonya.
Episode 9: We saw Roddy in lots of talks as the HoH, and although I'm tempted to give a point to Gerry for accepting Roddy's deal to stay off the block, I will give the point to Roddy.
Episode 10: We saw Eric win the veto and remain loyal to Roddy, as he kept the nominations the same. I'll give the point to Roddy I think, as he continued to get his way without having to win multiple competitions that would make him appear more threatening.
Episode 11: We didn't get much besides Amy and Marcellas fighting and Amy leaving unanimously, so the point goes to Gerry for winning HoH.
Episode 12: We heard that Josh, Roddy, and Marcellas came to Gerry to try and save themselves. We also heard about Jason and Danielle's secret alliance for the first time. There are a lot of people I could give a point to, but I will give the point to Jason.
Episode 13: We saw Chiara win the veto, and I'll give the point to Roddy for urging her not to use it as it would result in him going up, and it also proved that Chiara was now more on Roddy's side than Lisa's.
Episode 14: We got Josh blowing smoke getting Chiara to think Lisa hated her, but ultimately Lisa survived over Eric. We then saw Chiara win the HoH, so I suppose Chiara gets the point.
Episode 15: We saw Danielle bring the information that Chiara voted against Lisa to Lisa, which furthered the rift between them so Danielle gets the point.
Episode 16: We saw Lisa win the veto and then strategize with Danielle and Marcellas on how to get Roddy out. I think Lisa gets the point.
Episode 17: We didn't get much, Roddy and Josh fought over Josh campaigning against Roddy, and then we saw Amy win her way back into the house. I guess I will give the point to Amy.
Episode 18: We heard that Amy won HoH. And the HouseGuests will be greeted with a surprise visit by Grammy-nominated artist Sheryl Crow! I still think Amy gets the point.
Episode 19: We got to see generational talent Sheryl Crow visit the HouseGuests, while Chiara cried about the rules of the show. We do see Marcellas and Roddy form an alliance, and Roddy ended up on the block, so I suppose Marcellas gets this point.
Episode 20: Nothing really encouraged me to give a point to anybody except for Jason winning HoH, so he gets the point.
Episode 21: We see a push from others to nominate Roddy, while Roddy tried to convince Jason to keep him off the block. Roddy does end up staying off the block, but I still give the point to Jason.
Episode 22: We still see that others want to take Roddy out but he's been able to remain in the house through his "power of persuasion." We see Jason sweep the week's competitions and he locks in his nominees, so Jason gets this point as well.
Episode 23: We didn't see much this episode besides Gerry getting sent home, and Marcellas winning HoH, so I guess Marcellas gets the point.
Episode 24: We see Marcellas put Roddy up to get evicted, but I don't really love this play from him, I give the point to Danielle.
Episode 25: We saw Amy win the PoV and everyone worried that she would use it on Roddy. Ultimately that would probably get her evicted, and in the end she chose not to so I guess Amy gets the point.
Episode 26: We saw more about Amy not using the veto, and we saw Roddy get predictably evicted, and we saw Jason winning the HoH. So I guess Jason gets the point.
Episode 27: We saw Danielle convince Marcellas to not use the veto on himself, while also winning the F4 HoH, so she easily gets this point.
Episode 28: We saw Jason kind of accidentally clue Lisa off to the secret alliance, which is sort of inconsequential but it's enough to give Danielle the point.
Episode 29: We didn't get a ton of gameplay from this one, we see Lisa and Danielle talking game while Jason and Amy are out on a boat somewhere. We also see Jason and Danielle celebrate making it to the final 3 without being nominated. I guess I'll give the point to Lisa for seemingly initiating the game talk.
Episode 30: We see Jason send Amy out and the start of the final HoH. With Amy gone, Jason wins in two out of 3 final HoH scenarios, so Jason gets the point.
Episode 31: We see Lisa win the final HoH and evict Jason, so Lisa gets the point.
Episode 32: Obviously there was no Previously On as this was the final episode, but Lisa won this episode so she gets the point.
FINAL RANKINGS
12. Lori Olson: 0 points
11. Tonya Paoni: 0 points
10. Eric Oullette: 0 points
09. Josh Feinberg: 1 point
08. Chiara Berti: 1 point
07. Gerry Lancaster: 2 points
06. Roddy Mancuso: 3 points
05. Amy Crews: 3 points
04. Marcellas Reynolds: 5 points
03. Danielle Reyes: 5 points
02. Jason Guy: 6 points
01. Lisa Donahue: 6 points
This ranking I think is much less accurate than BB2's. I would definitely put Amy a bit lower, as well as Marcellas. Marcellas having 5 points is crazy. Danielle/Jason/Lisa I think all do belong on the top 3, and I might stick Jason at 1 and Danielle at 2 but I'm not mad at the way it is currently. I think Eric should probably be above the Amys and Chiaras of the world, and I think Roddy is a very underrated player, I would put Roddy as the #4 best player on this cast.
