Determining which game of Survivor was the most exciting based on what happened each round. I started one of these for Big Brother, but Big Brother isn't nearly as good and honestly I'm not as familiar with every season of Big Brother as opposed to my virgin-like knowledge of Survivor.
Random.org selects ONE WORLD and ALL STARS to go head to head against each other.
FINAL 18 - Kourtney Boot vs. Tina Boot - Kourtney was medevaced. POINT: AS (1-0)
FINAL 17 - Nina Boot vs. Rudy Boot - Both relatively boring boots, but Ethan being able to survive the vote as a past winner is fun. POINT: AS (2-0)
FINAL 16 - Matt Boot vs. Jenna M. Boot - Jenna quit the game. POINT: OW (2-1)
FINAL 15 - Bill Boot vs. Rob C. Boot - While the men giving up immunity is fun, the tribal lis a little icky, so I'll give the point to the Cesternino blindside. POINT: AS (3-1)
FINAL 14 - Monica Boot vs. Richard Boot - Although both were fun blindsides, Richard's vote out was going to happen soon either way. POINT: OW (3-2)
FINAL 13 - Colton Boot vs. Sue Boot - Both quits. Sue's was more uncomfortable, while for people who hated Colton, it may have been nice to see him go. Also funny when he kept the idol instead of giving it to an ally. POINT: OW (3-3)
FINAL 12 - Jonas Boot vs. Colby Boot - The Colby blindside is an underrated episode, and a fun addition to Jerri/Colby's story arc. POINT: AS (4-3)
FINAL 11 - Michael Boot vs. Ethan Boot - Kim lying to Troyzan about Michael targeting him, leaving Michael to be voted out is great. POINT: OW (4-4)
FINAL 10 - Jay Boot vs. Jerri Boot - Jay is frustratingly stupid. Amber being sent over as the only Chapera and surviving the vote thanks to a few words from Rob to Lex is so fun to watch. POINT: AS (5-4)
FINAL 9 - Leif Boot vs. Lex Boot - BRUTAL Lex boot is super memorable. Leif boot is just a continuation of the girls steamrolling all the men. POINT: AS (6-4)
FINAL 8 - Troyzan Boot vs. Kathy Boot - Honestly, both boring boots due to Pagongings. I guess I'll give it to OW, since the Kathy boot was due to a lot of them being stupid rather than OW, where Troyzan leaving makes more sense. POINT: OW (6-5)
FINAL 7 - Kat Boot vs. Alicia Boot - These are both sweet. Kat talking about how fun blindsides are before she gets blindsided, and Alicia refusing to talk any game with Shii Ann, leaving her with no options once Shii Ann wins immunity. I have to give it to AS. POINT: AS (7-5)
FINAL 6 - Tarzan Boot vs. Shii Ann Boot - Both just the ends of a Pagonging. The Tarzan boot seemed to have more happen before it, more was up in the air, while Shii Ann was kind of dead in the water. POINT: OW (7-6)
FINAL 5 - Alicia Boot vs. Big Tom Boot - Both fun blindsides. I think watching Alicia as the larger villain who thinks she's more in the loop than she is getting left out of final 3 plans is ultimately more fun though. POINT: OW (7-7)
FINAL 4 - Christina Boot vs. Rupert Boot - The Rupert boot is more fun because it's really honestly hard to wager what the best move strategically for Jenna is. And Christina just kind of laid dead. POINT: AS (8-7)
FINAL 3 - Kim Win vs. Jenna Boot - Jenna's boot was inevitable once Rob won immunity. Kim getting her deserved win was nice. POINT: OW (8-8)
FINAL 2 - Amber Win - Well, it all comes down to this. Was Amber's win satisfying or unsatisfying? As controversial as it may be, I think it is. Amber and Rob made the same moves, but Rob was the one who got the most blood on his hands. Plus, proposal. POINT: AS (9-8)
SEASONS THAT ARE STILL IN:
Borneo
Australian Outback
Africa
Marquesas
Thailand
The Amazon
Pearl Islands
Vanuatu
Palau
Guatemala
Exile Island
Cook Islands
Fiji
China
Micronesia
Gabon
Tocantins
Samoa
Heroes vs. Villains
Nicaragua
Redemption Island
South Pacific
Philippines
Caramoan
Blood vs. Water
Cagayan
San Juan del Sur
Worlds Apart
Cambodia
Kaoh Rong
Millennials vs. Gen X
Game Changers
Heroes vs. Healers vs. Hustlers
Ghost Island
David vs. Goliath
Edge of Extinction
Juliann There are some good characters, and Kim's game is totally awesome. The problem is, when someone plays as good a game as Kim did, it leads to the season becoming a little boring
