I only cast people who weren't in the original HvV.
HEROES:
Ian
Ozzy
Yau-Man
Troyzan
Malcolm
Taj
Natalie W.
Brenda
Andrea
Kat
NOTES: Natalie W. may be a bit of a question mark, but it was hard finding heroic females and it'd be good to have a past winner on the tribe. Brenda was a villain on her original season, but after Caramoan she's definitely a hero. I find Andrea to be boring, but I know a lot of people like her.
VILLAINS:
Judd
Shane
Penner
Todd
Reynold
Natalie B.
Crystal
Corinne
Sophie
Kim
NOTES: Kim wasn't really a villain with her personality, but her gameplay was pretty cutthroat. Sophie was viewed as a "brat". We also see the return of Massive Crystal < 3 and FINALLY get a returnee from Guatemala
Comments
Natalie W was a hero in my mind too, she was sweet but still got the job done.
