Kelly was a castaway on Survivor: Worlds Apart and was part of the Escameca (Blue Collar) tribe originally. As a state trooper, she kept her occupation a secret, after the success of Sarah and Tony on Cagayan. She immediately formed a connected, and later an alliance, with Mike Holloway. They would include Dan and Rodney into their alliance as well. Kelly enjoyed safety due to Escameca winning the first three immunity challenges. During one memorable blindfold challenge, Kelly ran into something and blood started running down her face, causing Jeff to pause the challenge. They lost immunity for the first time on Day 11. After Rodney and Lindsey had an explosive argument, the two targeted each other. Kelly鈥檚 alliance decided to split the vote between Lindsey and her ally Sierra, with the two of them targeting Rodney. After a 3-way tie, Lindsey was sent home. The very next day there was a tribe swap, with the 3 tribes becoming 2. Kelly went from Escameca to Nagarote and was the sole Blue Collar on her new tribe, possibly setting her up to be tribe fucked.