In my eyes, two things make a legend. 1. Being a great character and 2. Being a great player. So, I've decided to figure out who the biggest Survivor legend is by taking the two top confessional getters (ties broken by placement) and deciding who played better that episode, giving them a point. Whoever has the most points after I go through every season is the biggest Survivor legend.
Ep. 1
Sean Rector v. Rob Mariano
Sean was on the wrong side of the vote, so Rob gets this point.
Ep. 2
John Carroll v. Hunter Ellis
Hunter was on the wrong side of the vote, so John gets this point.
Ep. 3
John Carroll v. Hunter Ellis
Hunter was voted out this episode, so John gets this point.
Ep. 4
Kathy Vavrick-O'Brien v. Gina Crews
It was really Gina's idea to get rid of Sarah, so she gets this point.
Ep. 5
John Carroll v. Gina Crews
Although John was in a little bit of danger, he organized an alliance and the entire Gabriel vote, so John gets this point.
Ep. 6
Rob Mariano v. Gina Crews
Gina was voted out this episode, so Rob gets this point.
Ep. 7
Kathy Vavrick-O'Brien v. Rob Mariano
Rob was voted out this episode, so Kathy gets this point.
Ep. 8
Kathy Vavrick-O'Brien v. Paschal English
Kathy was the one pushing for Neleh and Paschal to flip, so Kathy gets this point as well.
Ep. 9
Paschal English v. Sean Rector
Pretty uneventful episode for gameplay, but Paschal was approached with more offers, so he gets this point.
Ep. 10
Paschal English v. Sean Rector
Again a pretty uneventful episode game-wise, but Paschal upset people with his choice to bring Neleh on the reward, so Sean gets this point.
Ep. 11
Kathy Vavrick-O'Brien v. Robert DeCanio
Robert was voted out this episode, so Kathy gets this point.
Ep. 12
Kathy Vavrick-O'Brien v. Sean Rector
Sean was voted out this episode, so Kathy gets this point.
Ep. 13
Vecepia Towery v. Neleh Dennis
Vecepia won the game this episode, so she gets this point.
SEASON TOTAL
Kathy Vavrick-O'Brien - 4 points
John Carroll - 3 points
Rob Mariano - 2 points
Vecepia Towery - 1 point
Paschal English - 1 point
Sean Rector - 1 point
Gina Crews - 1 point