I was just interested to see how this would shake out, I gave the winner of each season the # of points based on how many contestants there were, the runner up half of that, the 3rd placer half of that, and so on until it would fall below 1.
I will now compose a ranking of them, and to make the cut, I'll say you have to have at least 10 points (the lowest amount of points a winner has.)
27. Eddie McGee - 10 points
26. Marissa Jaret Winokur - 11 points
25. Enzo Palumbo - 11.25 points
23-24. (Those who only won a 12 HG season) Lisa Donahue & Tamar Braxton - 12 points
20-22. (Those who only won a 13 HG season) Jun Song, Hayden Moss, & Morgan Willett - 13 points
19. Will Kirby - 13.75 points
14-18. (Those who only won a 14 HG season) Drew Daniel, Maggie Ausburn, Mike Boogie, Evel Dick, & Rachel Reilly
13. Jordan Lloyd - 14.75 points
7-12. (Those who only won a 16 HG season) Adam Jasinski, Ian Terry, Andy Herren, Derrick Levasseur, Kaycee Clark, & Jackson Michie - 16 points
6. Paul Abrahamian - 16.5 points
4-5. (Those who only won a 17 HG season) Steve Moses & Josh Martinez - 17 points
3. Nicole Franzel - 20 points
2. Dan Gheesling - 21 points
1. Cody Calafiore - 24 points
Tester I am shocked at how I'm being negged, because I pretty clearly stated my method and just did it out of curiosity and boredom. Obviously I don't think that Dick and Rachel are better players than Will, and I don't think that Steve and Josh are top 5 players ever.
Dick is the worst winner ever tbh