Putting the cast up against each other and picking out which made better TV - the further you went, the more you're worth.
As Philippines only had 18 castaways, Candice and Rupert will not count. Since Lisa and Skupin tied for 2nd, whoever Wikipedia has listed right under the winner will count as 2nd for the sake of the format.
1 point - Zane Knight > Marissa Peterson
2 points - Roxy Morris > Rachel Foulger
3 points - Angie Layton > Colton Cumbie
4 points - Russell Swan > John Cody
5 points - Dana Lambert < Brad Culpepper
6 points - Sarah Dawson < Kat Edorrson
7 points - Katie Hanson < Laura Boneham
8 points - RC Saint-Amour > Aras Baskauskas
9 points - Jeff Kent < Vytas Baskauskas
10 points - Artis Silvester < Laura Morett
11 points - Pete Yurkowski > Caleb Bankston
12 points - Jonathan Penner > Katie Collins
13 points - Carter Williams < Hayden Moss
14 points - Abi-Maria Gomes > Ciera Eastin
15 points - Malcolm Freberg > Tina Wesson
16 points - Lisa Whelchel > Gervase Peterson
17 points - Michael Skupin < Monica Culpepper
18 points - Denise Stapley < Tyson Apostol
By a score of 86-85, the superior cast, moving onto the top 10 is...
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Philippines!
TOP 10
David vs. Goliath
Heroes vs. Healers vs. Hustlers
Kaoh Rong
Philippines
South Pacific/Nicaragua
Heroes vs. Villains/Tocantins
Micronesia/Cook Islands
Panama/Vanuatu
Pearl Islands/Amazon
Africa/Borneo