Tried to keep things as realistic as possible, while also including cast members from all eras of the show, and keeping the gender balance even. 20 cast members. Some people on here aren't even my favorites, but I feel like I had to include them. A twist where the 10 play amongst themselves, until both squads reach the final 5, and have to play from 10 again.
CHAMPS
Will Kirby (Big Brother 2, Big Brother All Stars)
Dan Gheesling (Big Brother 10, Big Brother 14)
Derrick Levasseur (Big Brother 16)
Mike Boogie (Big Brother 2, Big Brother All Stars, Big Brother 14)
Jackson Michie (Big Brother 21)
Nicole Franzel (Big Brother 16, Big Brother 18)
Rachel Reilly (Big Brother 12, Big Brother 13)
Maggie Ausburn (Big Brother 6)
Lisa Donahue (Big Brother 3)
Jordan Lloyd (Big Brother 11, Big Brother 13)
LEGENDS
James Huling (Big Brother 17, Big Brother 18)
Paul Abrahamian (Big Brother 18, Big Brother 19)
John McGuire (Big Brother 17)
Cody Nickson (Big Brother 19)
Enzo Palumbo (Big Brother 12)
Janelle Pierzina (Big Brother 6, Big Brother All Stars, Big Brother 14)
Daniele Donato (Big Brother 8, Big Brother 13)
Vanessa Rousso (Big Brother 17)
Alison Irwin (Big Brother 4, Big Brother All Stars)
Danielle Reyes (Big Brother 3, Big Brother All Stars)
FINAL 10
Will Kirby (Big Brother 2, Big Brother All Stars)
Dan Gheesling (Big Brother 10, Big Brother 14)
Derrick Levasseur (Big Brother 16)
Mike Boogie (Big Brother 2, Big Brother All Stars, Big Brother 14)
Jackson Michie (Big Brother 21)
Nicole Franzel (Big Brother 16, Big Brother 18)
Rachel Reilly (Big Brother 12, Big Brother 13)
Maggie Ausburn (Big Brother 6)
Lisa Donahue (Big Brother 3)
Jordan Lloyd (Big Brother 11, Big Brother 13)
The HoH boils down to Nicole and Lisa.... and old schooler Lisa wins the first HoH. Lisa decides to go after the more new school players, she puts up Derrick, one of the biggest strategists ever, and Nicole, who knows him from playing with him. Lisa draws HG choice and picks Rachel, Boogie and Maggie are also picked. The PoV comes down to the two nominees, Derrick and Nicole. Boogie threw the challenge. Derrick ends up winning it. Since Derrick saves himself, Lisa has to put somebody else up, and decides to go after another one of the GOATs, Dan Gheesling. The pressure of the game gets to Jordan, leading her to have an emotional moment. Maggie says something inappropriate in conversation. Jordan and Rachel decide to target Dan, leaving Dan with 2 votes. Maggie also votes against Dan, leaving him with 3. However, Chilltown + Michie votes against Nicole to keep Dan around as a meatshield, and as a potential ally since he and Boogie played together. Which leaves it to Derrick, who does not want to have the target on his back for knowing Nicole, so he evicts Nicole 4-3.
FINAL 9
Michie/Boogie/Will
Jordan/Rachel
Dan/Boogie
The HoH comes down to Jordan and Maggie, two people who were on the wrong side of the vote last round. Jordan ends up winning it. Jordan decides to target Chilltown, and she nominates Boogie and Michie, because she felt that they were the 2 most likely to win the PoV, and if they won, she could just put Dr. Will up. Michie draws HG choice and picks Dan. Will and Maggie are also picked to compete. The PoV ends up coming down to Will and Boogie, and Jordan's plans don't work out when Dr. Will wins. Will obviously saves his longtime friend Boogie, leaving Jordan to put somebody else up next to Michie. She decides to put up a Chilltown affiliate and pawn, Lisa. Jordan opens up to Rachel by sharing a story, continuing their bond. Derrick and Dr. Will don't get along game wise, and start to think that they may go after each other next. Dan throws a vote towards Michie, but everybody else votes Lisa out before she can fly under the radar, proving Chilltown's influence on the house.
FINAL 8
The alliance of Dan and Boogie kind of dissolves.
Michie/Boogie/Will
Jordan/Rachel
The HoH comes down to Rachel and Boogie, two people who seem to be on different sides of the house. Rachel ends up winning. Rachel sees the rivalry that Derrick and Will have, and takes it as an opportunity to ride the fence and nominate both of them. Rachel draws HG choice and picks Jordan. Boogie and Maggie are drawn to compete. The PoV comes down to Maggie and Rachel, but Maggie pulls out a victory. Maggie sees no reason to use the veto, so she leaves Derrick and Will on the block. Jordan continues to open up to Rachel. The pressure of the game gets to Maggie, leaving her to have a bit of a breakdown. Boogie tries to improve his social standing with everybody in the house, and Derrick campaigns hard against Dr. Will. Michie and Boogie vote for Derrick to go, but the other 3 voters don't want Chilltown to continue running the house so Jordan, Maggie, and Dan blindside Dr. Will.
FINAL 7
Michie/Boogie
Jordan/Rachel
The next HoH comes down to Jordan and Maggie. Maggie continues her win streak and wins HoH. She decides to nominate Dan and Jordan, even though she just voted with them, but Jordan is a pawn, and this is a good week to get rid of Dan. Boogie, Michie, and Rachel are drawn to compete. The PoV comes down to two people not in danger, Michie and Rachel. Rachel couldn't win it for her ally, as Michie wins the PoV. Michie wants to keep Boogie safe, so he does not use the Power of Veto. Rachel is upset Jordan is on the block, and begins planting seeds in people's heads that Maggie should go next. Rachel is aligned with Jordan so she votes Dan, as does Derrick because Dan is the bigger threat. However, Michie and Boogie want to split up the Jordan/Rachel duo, so they vote Jordan. Leaving the HoH, Maggie, to make the final call. Maggie follows through with her original plan and evicts Dan from the house.
FINAL 6
Michie/Boogie
Jordan/Rachel
The HoH comes down to Michie and Rachel, two people from opposing duos. Michie wins another competition and becomes the HoH. He however rides the fence, and puts up Rachel and Maggie, since Rachel had been campaigning against her so hard. Everyone competes in the PoV. The PoV comes down to Derrick and nominee Rachel. Derrick ends up winning. Derrick chose not to use the PoV as he didn't see any point in mixing things up. Someone shouts from outside the house that Derrick is not to be trusted and Rachel has a breakdown. Jordan wants Maggie out, and Boogie and Derrick both decide to play nice with Jordan/Rachel so that they'll take them to the 3, and they evict Maggie 3-0.
FINAL 5
Michie/Boogie
Jordan/Rachel
The winners are about to find out that they are not in the final 5, but really in the final 10, and are about to meet the final 5 challengers.
Will the winner be Mike Boogie, Jordan Lloyd, Rachel Reilly, Derrick Levasseur, or Jackson Michie? Or will it be one of the 5 losing legends? How will the two houses meeting shake up the dynamics?
