My Opinion, Post if u agree, disagree, who u think should be what.
1. Sandra: she annoys me immensely but u cant argue with 2 wins out of 2. Weak in challenges but has amazing jury management. Slides under radar but wins
2. Parvati: Robbed in HvV in my opinion, great physical, social and strategic player. Able to manoeuvre herself into powerful positions, make bold plays and strong in challenges
3. Boston Rob: Great all around player but didn't do so well in Marquesas' or HvV. Absolutely dominated in Redemption Island and finally won. Great in challenges
4. Richard Hatch: Pure amazing, hilarious, funny. Not higher as he did play with nubes.Not sure how he would go in a new season but a great player.
5. Kim: She dominated her season, physically she owned them all. She outwitted everyone, managed to backstab a lot of people and Win
6. Yul: Donimated his season, great social player who could manipulate well. Alligned with the right people and found an idol. Godfather
7. Cirie: For a physically weak player she kicks ass strategically and socially. In Micronesia played a great strategic game but was overshadowed by Parvati
8. Rob Cesterino: Funniest Confessionals/jury vote offs. Great Strategic player but doesn't have resume to back it up
9. Ozzy: In Cook Islands was possibly the most physically strong player (besides AO Colby). Fun to watch and a massive threat
10. Amanda: Great physical player who can align great but has horrible jury management. Some may disagree but I am basing this on two great seasons and one mediocre.
11. Rupert: Great asset to many tribes and he has always got a great pre merge game but sucks when it comes time to merge. Physically strong as hell
12. Russel: May get some crap for putting him here but all he does is find idols. In an earlier season without idols he would be one of the first voted out. He may outwit but he lacks jury management.
13. Todd: Managed to get himself to the end playing a fairl cut throat game but also was funny. Managed to win
14. J.T - A great person. physically strong, sort of threw Stephan under the bus when he kind of did all of the strategic and it showed in HvV with his dumbass move
15. Jerri: She really did age better with time. I loved her gameplay in heroes vs viallains, She redeemed herself and she made it pretty far. Funny to watch her bitching and makes it interesting
16. Tom: I kind of forgot about him, he was a great player in Palau but kind stunk it all in HvV otherwise would have easily been in top 10. Lacks strategic game a little not immensely but a little and not as physically fit as he was
17. Chris: Managed to turn all the women on eachother although he was annoying to watch, but cudos to him.
18. Colby: Really was the best physically player in his prime but in All stars and HvV, he kind of seemed dull and was only brought back in my opinion based on his fame from season 2
19: Coach: A weirdo and a half but in South Pacific I realised that hey he actually can do something.
20: Natalie Bolton: Hilariously funny to watch,not sure why she aint ever come back as she was a great character
1.Yes
2.Only in HVV
3.Yes even though his win was kinda bullshit
4.Yes
5.Yes
6.yeah i guess..
7.Yessss
8.hmmm meh yeah
9.No, he only has physical skills
10.Yes
11.No
12.No
13.Yes
14.Over-rated
15.Yes
16.Yeah but Palau sucked soo
17.Yes
18.Yes
19.50/50
20.No
3, 6, 9, 11, 12, 16, and 19 I would never put on a top 20 list. The winners only won because of the season they where on. Rob would never win again and needs absolute Zombies to do so. Tom has shown several times in Paulu he is a horrid Socail game and not good at stratgey either. yul only won because of a OP idol otherwise he would be just another pagong victum that no one rembers. He would never have won that season with the other idol. The other players mention absolutly suck horridly and would never win.
manalord It isn't fair to critisize Yul for using the overpowered idol to advance. That was a part of the game, and he used it brilliantly. It wasn't an unfair advantage since everyone had an equal chance to find it. Saying he wouldn't have won without that idol is like saying that Danni would never had won if there had been no immunity advantage at the auction, or that Chris would never have won if there had been no loved ones visit (it made the women feel sorry for him and want to keep him longer) all the winners benefitted from twists.
masterchef It is fair to say he is not a brilliant player because he showed he lacked the abillity to play without the idol. I think his game had flaws and that idol shows them. The fact is Yul is another Danni or Natalie or Chris or Sandra or Parvarti that you either think is an amazing winner or you think is lower-mid/bottom teir. For most of them there is no middle ground
