1. Erik Gives individual immunity to grant himself final 4, FINAL 4 and to an all female alliance I mean cmon dude what were u thinking but beautifully done by the women
2. James has to idols and doesn't play either of them with only 3 opportunities in which he could have played them, cmon did he not see that one coming like seriously, it as kinda obvious.
3. Brandon Hantz gives up immunity, he is a stupid idiot like I mean wtf was he thinking, he was an annoying praying stupid dumbass
4. J.t gives up hidden Idol to Russel, did he think Russel was placed on that tribe for helping people, like cmon what are u doing J.t
5. Cochran Flipping ion south pacific achieved absolutely nothing, all he did was screw over his entire tribe and achieve nothing, he didn't exactly do any better, I cant get over how over rated Cochran is, he is horrible and only won because everyone else was a bigger target
6. Jason not playing his idol, he just saw ozzy get blindsided the exact same way but yet he still believes that he will be safe like wtf is wrong with him
7.Purple Kelly quitting - is it me or did she just kinda do it for no reason as if Naonka is quitting so why don't I, she had no reason to quit
8. Dawn blindsiding Brenda, she was an idiot, that's all, it had no reasoning at that point
I got so mad at some of these. Eriks was hillarious though. Thats just stupidity. What about I think it was matt? Who was blindsided by his tribe in redemption island, makes it back into the game only to go right back to the people who voted him out so they could do it again.
1. Erik's said it himself, he didn't expect to make friends out here. He did what he did because he did want to clear his name out with the women. Survivor's a lot harder than you'd expect.
2. James trusted his alliance, as most would, and didn't expect them to turn.
3. It was either Brandon or Albert going home, although Brandon didn't know that he would've gone home, because he was thinking Sophie would go instead, but wouldn't've gone if he didn't give the necklace to Albert.
4. JT, along with everyone else in HvV, did not get to see how Russell played. They didn't know he ran All-Girl alliances, so expected him to be on the outs.
5. His team wasn't nice to him, as we saw on TV. So his 'revenge' for that, or payback, was to flip. Besides, when they didn't want him, Upolu did. As for his win, there may have been bigger threats but he and Dawn were the ones who executed them. The only reason Dawn didn't win was because Dawn had stabbed in the front whereas Cochran stabbed in the back.
6. Not sure what to say with Jason.
7. PK was basically miserable on the island. She had a different set of clothes, but CBS made her change them into what we saw on the island. If I'm correct she had a nice sundress or something. So she was cold, wet, and in the same situation as NaOnka.
8. Dawn blindsiding Brenda was a controversial move. Brenda is strong, she is smart, and she proved that she can make people happy, which would have worked well for her in the long run. There was no idiocy in that move, and it did have reason.
9. Randy's idol was very real-looking. They had thrown the idol out, but Randy got a good look at it before it had been thrown out. So when Bob gave Randy the fake idol (note: Bob also saw the idol that the threw into the ocean), Randy thought it was real.
10. Eliza playing the idol was just an "in-case" moment.
Some moves are dumb on paper, but all of them (most of the time), did have reasoning.
1. Erik thought he would have 0 Jury votes in the end. I mean, he would already be down 4 votes (all 4 girls) at the final 2, so he would have needed all of the other votes just to get a tie. He thought Amanda was a Jury threat (lol look how that turned out) so he had to take a chance. He could have stayed in the game longer, but he wouldn't have won in the end.
2. As 01Gohan said, James trusted his allies. If I were James, I would have played it, because since he's so physically fit, I'm sure he would have won at least one Immunity out of f6 and f5. However it's just a blind side. People aren't stupid for getting blind sided.
3. Brandon Hantz is a dumb ass. Nuff said.
4. JT didn't see Samoa because it was airing while they were out on Survivor. He didn't see that he was known for making women's alliances, and he thought that the Villains was an all-girls tribe vs. Russell. Russell would have played the Idol, voted out Parvati, then flipped to the Heroes at merge, and then they would have taken out Sandra, Jerri, Danielle, and Courtney. Russell would be the next to go after that, and it would be a Heroes final 5 (or if JT were smart, final 4, without Rupert) and then he could have won some Immunities to get to the final 3 and potentially win.
5. I'll agree that Cochran's flip was stupid. He, being the survivor fanatic that he is, should have known that flippers never win. Susie from Gabon got to the end, but she lost. However, his tribe was just flat out rude to him, so he knew he could at least hope to get somewhere with Upolu, or be guaranteed 6th on Savaii. Cochran played an excellent game in Survivor so no, you're wrong about his win.
6. Yes, that was a dumb move. I mean he knew that he was next on the chopping block and just didn't play it. Like...
7. She quit because it was unpleasant for her... That's why people quit Survivor... I do agree that had NaOnka stayed, Kelly would have stayed, but that's not stupid, that's psychology.
8. It was a smart move to take out Brenda. Brenda built friendships with everyone and was a huge challenge threat. She could have easily won in the final 3.
9. Randy had no reason to believe it was a fake Idol, and he had no other options. What could he do, not play the Idol and hope it wasn't him that night? He would have been voted off regardless of whether or not he had played it.
10. Eliza knew she probably was being voted out. Just like Randy, there was nothing else she could do. Eliza used that to call Ozzy out, turning everyone against him, and getting him voted out later. Eliza didn't think she was going to get anywhere, because she knew it was most likely fake. However, she couldn't do anything but hope that it was the real thing.
couldn't agree more with everything you said for #5!!!!
I would probably replace Eliza with Alex from Amazon...he told Rob he would vote him out at F4, so Rob blindsided him at the next tribal council. Eliza knew it wasn't the idol but she had nothing to lose by playing it
