In past seasons I liked to pose a question about a game move from BB and see if people agreed or disagreed.
THERE WILL BE SPOILERS ABOUT THIS WEEK'S HOH & POV NOMS
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Last eviction, Ian was evicted by a vote of 5 to 3. However, Nicole Franzel had the ability to tie the vote at 4-4, and Dani would have broken the tie between Tyler and Ian. In the points below, I am grouping Dani & Nicole together because the would have worked together to make this move.
In YOUR opinion, did Nicole and Dani make the right decision to seal Ian's fate?
Pros of keeping Ian over Tyler:
~Ian has no close allies AT ALL except Nicole. He was a lap-puppy for Nicole and would have likely sheeped her til the end
~Tyler has distrusted Dani for several weeks now, and her putting him up last week was the confirmation that she doesn't have his back
~Tyler has proven to be a stronger competitor than Ian this season, posing as a comp threat when the alliance has to crumble
~When the alliance does crumble, Ian would have been a number for Nicole/Dani
Pros of keeping Tyler:
~The alliance would still be in-tact. Evicting Tyler would have likely upset Enzo, Memphis. Christmas, and possibly Cody
~Keeping Tyler means that you have a strong competitor who could possibly keep you safe as long as the alliance is still together
~Ian did very well in his first season with the competitions in the latter half of the game (but so did Tyler). Ian was very clutch when his back was against the wall
****SPOILERS BELOW****
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
As we move through this week, new information may prove that Nicole needed Ian. Da'Vonne is the current target and is likely being sent home on Thursday, which would be ANOTHER person in this game who trusted mainly Nicole being sent out the door.
Nicole and Dani are slowly being excluded from new alliances and deals. Memphis/Enzo/Cody/Christmas have all been making deals with each other, forming bonds that will end with Nicole and Dani getting burned.
Off course they don't know this shifting power, but in the wise words of Bayleigh "if you swing you better not miss"
They evict Tyler, Memphis still wins HoH, Memphis now nominates Dani and Nicole as a result of going behind the alliance's back, they get evicted back to back.
Sure, everyone can shit on them for not saving Ian, but evicting him was likely the right move for Dani at least anyway.
I don鈥檛 think it was a mistake. Sadly, they were one eviction too late in changing stuff. If Nicole has tied it, the committee would turn against her (and there鈥檚 plenty of them still to do that) and we all know Dani would not have saved Ian, anyway.
