This is a season idea. It's similar to Island Of The Idols, but not the same!
Each episode, one person is taken to another island. Half the island is split up into heaven, and the other half hell. In the heaven zone, is one of the most heroic players of all time, and in hell is one of the most evil of all time.
When the castaway arrives on the island, they will go into a neutral zone, and the heroic player and the evil player will greet them. They will both try to get the castaway onto their side. Once the castaway has picked their side, the returnee will then teach them a lesson, then offer them a challenge in exchange for an advantage
In heaven, all of the advantages will favor you (Eg: Extra vote, Immunity advantage) meanwhile hell will offer items that will hurt another player's game (Eg: Vote blocker, Immunity handicap)
This is where the twist gets more complex, and I might remove this...because it might be a little controversial...
Once a player gets voted out, they also head to this island. If that castaway has already been there, they will default to whichever side they chose when they first visited, but if they haven't visited yet, then the returnees need to try and tempt them to their side. They will go to the side they chose, and live there until the time comes...
When it reaches the final 5 in the main game, everyone on both sides will compete in an immunity challenge against the opposing side. The tribe that loses will all get eliminated from the game. The tribe that wins then goes to back to back tribal councils until there's three castaways left, and the returnee.
The three left will then be tested on something they learned on the island (Eg: How to make fire, how to build a raft) and if they pass their test, the players in-game must vote somebody out, and then the two players swap.
Once all three have done their task, and the swaps have happened, the game continues as normal
EXAMPLE:
Heaven vs Hell island:
Anne
Kara
Amber
In-game:
Lucy
Jamie
Jeremy
Clark
Alex
John
Kara and Amber pass their tests, Anne fails
Alex and John are voted out, so Kara and Amber replace them
Out:
Anne
Alex
John
In-game:
Lucy
Jamie
Jeremy
Clark
Kara
Amber
So was this idea decent? Should I cut out the second chance part? Let me know!