Jeremiah was a castaway on Survivor: Cagayan and was a member of the Beauty/Solana tribe. He formed a tight bond with LJ, Alexis, and Jefra on the first day and they enjoyed safety after winning the first two immunity challenges. They lost the third immunity and Jeremiah was positioned as the swing vote, with the outsiders scrambling for his vote. Ultimately, he stuck with his alliance and joined them in splitting the votes between Morgan and Brice and upon the revote, he voted out Brice. Morgan was upset at Jeremiah betraying her, believing their alliance to be real. On day 12, he was swapped to the new Aparri tribe along with Morgan and Alexis. In order to put a target on him, Tony gave Jeremiah the clue to the Hidden Immunity Idol. When Aparri had to go to their only tribal council, they turned on each other and Alexis tried her best to get Jeremiah out, but he joined in unanimously voting her out.