JOHN
--------------------------
Ethan - for a long time this game, I did see you as the leader of the group that ruled the game. I commend you for that. However, being that we haven't spoken very much this season, that's only from my perception. I would love to hear more specifics than what you provided during your speech. Of you and Erik, you probably have the better chance at making a case for why you deserve the win.
I think a lot of the moves that the alliance made during premerge were generally group consensus things, but I did always believe that they benefited my game personally in addition to helping the entire alliance along. Taking out people who had a long list of pre existing loyalties was essential in the early game. Chili, Kelly, Ashanti, and attempts at Christian and Brian were votes that I was a part of. There was no one on the "other side" I would have been opposed to voting so I never felt the need to stick my neck out to push something through to save someone, but I did voice my preferences when things were up in the air including targeting Christian numerous times. As stated in my opening speech, during the first swap we were at a crucial point where we couldn't lose numbers on our alliance when the tribe was split 5-5 and we were facing rocks. No one on the other side could be convinced to flip so I used my non-crackheaded social skills to reason with Josh and get him to go to rocks with us while everyone else failed to read the situation and react in a way that would get results we wanted.
During the triple tribal at final 19, my name did come up at some point and it was Kyle and/or Erik that threw it out. I didn't think it would get much traction at that point but I did what I had to do to ensure that it never became a thing. I went to Ashanti and told him that I felt like it would be a split vote on himself and I and that I wanted to do something to change that and for some reason that finally got him scrambling when he hadn't scrambled all day which is the reason everyone got nervous about a potential idol in the first place. I believe that since I got Ashanti scrambling before tribal, I ensured that no split vote plan would happen and locked in my safety during that tribal.
I also made the personal choice to send Seth to Ghost Island at final 16. We had all agreed as an alliance that we would send John so that Seth and Luis would have 2 votes to tie at their tribal if they lost. I don't know if I was the only person to vote for Ghost Island or what but I got what I wanted. I had decided I didn't really care if Luis went home and I wasn't willing to lose Seth by any means so I voted him to go despite the alliance's plan. When he got a legacy advantage at Ghost Island that wouldn't help him in his 3-1 tribe split, I ended up creating a plan for him to bluff an idol if he got sent back to tribal. I got Ben to send me the Culebra idol "note" and forwarded it to Seth timestamped for when he was at Ghost Island so that he would have a believable idol to play around with and try to save himself.
At final 10 was probably the hardest move I made for myself, and that was the decision to flip on the alliance I'd been loyal to all game. It was a move meant to break up Livingston/Billy/Harry from being a potential trio. If I had my way, it would have been Livingston and not Billy going here. I knew I had Billy's trust and I didn't feel that he would be after me at any point, but I also knew my best path to the end was with Seth and Erik and Kyle as my core. If I had pushed to keep Billy in the game it would have brought question to my loyalty to the new core. Also having him around would have definitely continued to muddy my vision on the game as I would have wanted to keep protecting him. So cutting Billy was a very difficult decision but I think it was the right one for my game.
At final 9 I had to make a split second decision when I learned Seth had become the target and was receiving the majority of votes. At this point I had 2 idols in my pocket and I could have held them and let Seth go but that would have meant I was down on numbers at final 8 and could end up relying on immunity (whether challenges or idols) which is not how I wanted to play the game.
From final 8 on, the votes ultimately went the way I wanted with little problem. I was safe by my positioning as Christian's biggest threat and through my relationships specifically with Erik and Seth. I got votes all finale night courtesy of Christian and yet he could never convince anyone else to vote me until it was too late for them to save themselves.
I will say though, I anticipated going to rocks at 8 so I played my idol which turned out to be my biggest mistake in the game. I had no clue Livingston was under the impression we were voting Josh and I honestly didn't see why anyone would turn on their 4 at this point. But this move led to the merge idol being rehidden which Christian managed to find at some point during finale night between live challenges and 15 minute tribals.
So like I said, majority of the game I was able to lay back and let things run and still get my way. Despite being seen as a threat, I never had to worry too much because of my position. When I needed things to change and go my way, I jumped into action and did what I needed to do. I was never surprised by anything that happened in this game except for the vote where Hufus left and when Livingston threw his vote on Josh, and I think that shows I had a decent enough grasp and level of awareness around the game.