COMMENTS:
First of all, I must say this photo shoot is the hardest one so far. Admittedly, I also did my own research about these movies. I read synopsis. I also watched trailers and some clips. You can say that this photo shoot is also a challenge for us, the Judges.
So your theme this week is "Best Picture". Your goal is to capture the tone of the movie as a whole. Its mood. Its atmosphere. The editing. The weather, etc. It's not about portraying a certain character. It's about capturing the "feeling" it conveys to the viewers. At least that's what I've found out after my little research.
#TeamLUCKYDEVON AOKI (Mudbound) - I like your approach on the movie given to you. When I read the synopsis of the movie, I felt the hardship of the two races. There is inequality for sure. The inequality between two races. The movie also tackles the PTSD experiencing by the veterans during World War II. It has a gloomy tone and I kinda see that in your photo because of the black-and-white effect. But not completely due to the lack of expression on your face. The setting is good. When I look at the photo, I can say that it is somehow taken during the World War II.
HAO YUN XIANG (The Post) - You portrayed a character. You didn't capture the tone of the movie. You were given an advantage twice in a row and just like last week, you failed big time. I wanted to see struggle and dilemma in your photo and you missed it. I'm not a fan of this shot and it is totally missing the point of the whole photo shoot.
MILES McMILLAN (Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri) - The movie is about fighting for justice. It has a sad tone. Sadly, I don't see that in your photo. Black-and-white filter doesn't guarantee that the photo will look sad. Your photo doesn't fit your description at all. It's a profile shot, but I can see clearly that your facial expression doesn't convey sadness to the viewer. The body positioning doesn't help your case at all. Most of all, this photo has bad editing and not a Top Model photo material.
#TeamSUIGARRETT NEFF (Call Me By Your Name) - Oh. Is that Sean? My ultimate crush back in our cycle. Onto your photo, I can say that you capture the tone of the movie. I can see the desire and longing in your eyes. I can also see the struggle. Your explanation improved this week. The styling looks very 80s. I'm glad that you decided to go with a partner this round because it enhances your photo to give the overall tone of the movie.
IZI SIMUNDIC (Dunkirk) - Perfect! Once again, you captured the theme really well. I can see the suspense tone of the movie, everytime they are trying to evacuate, in your photo. I can see the struggle and hope in your eyes at the same time. The desperation on your face in the right photo totally got me. I didn't expect you will put two photos in one for this round but it worked just fine. I'm glad that you didn't portray a character, instead you went to portray the overall tone of the movie.
LENOX TILLMAN (Phantom Thread) - My favorite shot of you so far. I LOVE IT! Just looking at your eyes alone gives me chills. You're giving me that mysterious tone this twisted movie has. The styling is giving me the 1950s vibe. This is a REVELATION! This is my most favorite shot of the bunch so far. Thank you!
VICTORIA JUSTICE (I, Tonya) - You gave justice to the movie. Yes! The movie is about a woman who had a turbulent relationship with her mother. She grew up in an abusive environment and got married years after to a husband, who is physically abusing her. But that didn't stop her from moving forward. That's what I'm seeing in this photo. A woman who is a victim of abuse, but still moving forward to achieve her dream. You captured the tone of the movie minus the humorous tone. Overall, you did a good job.
#TeamMARLONDINARA CHETYROVA (The Shape of Water) - I was expecting something different, but I think the photo worked for the theme somehow. You chose to show us the struggle in your eyes and I think you did a good job on that. This photo, honestly, is kinda missing the overall tone of the movie. I can see the sadness, but I can't see the positive tone, which I saw in the movie.
DOUTZEN KROES (Get Out) - Reading your description I can sense that you did get the gist of the story. It's about slavery. Not just about transplanting white people's brains inside black people's body. Your photo captured the suspense tone of the movie. I like how you portrayed captivity and insanity in your photo.
MATTHEW NOSZKA (Lady Bird) - This is like a photo you had submitted during Week 1. A still shot from a TV series or a movie. This photo doesn't capture the tone of the movie at all. Your explanation and the photo don't support each other. I wanted to see in your photo the struggle of embracing one's self. This photo is so out of place for this theme.
SHAWN MENDES (Darkest Hours) - Another black-and-white photo from you, Shawn. Well it's not my issue this time. It's about you not comprehending the theme. In the movie, Churchill is all about leading the battle. Taking initiative. But when I look at your photo, I'm seeing a lazy man slouching on a couch and just waiting for his luck. The styling is good, but it doesn't enough to capture the tone of the movie. You were given a second chance, Shawn, but you didn't utilize it well.