I am sticking to the 12 person format from season 2. It just makes it easier to cast an even amount of men and women.
NOTE: I think with all this covid stuff CBS will keep this cast close to their own. I will explain further below.
----
THE 6 MEN:
Bobby Moynihan - Honestly shocked he hasn't been on it yet, he has done a LOT with BB in the past
Boy George - Appeals to the older generation. Has done Celebrity Apprentice and The Voice UK before so clearly is into reality TV.
Darius Rucker - I know two musicians is a bit of a stretch but they need to appeal to the yee-haw crowd and he is a big name in that genre but not so big that they will have to pay an arm and a leg
Dennis Rodman - Basketball legend. Same as George, he has reality TV experience.
Gable Stevenson - Olympic gold medalist
Johnny Bananas - Look, I don't want it either but with The Challenge All-Stars being a Paramount+ exclusive, they may want him as representation
----
THE 6 WOMEN:
Eileen Davidson - Two reasons, she is a former reality tv star and is a part of one of CBS' longest-running shows Young and the Restless. I chose her because she is a lot younger than her co-stars on YATR and can do comps
Kaley Cuoco - Sis is going through a divorce, she needs the $$$. Also appeals to the still large Big Bang Theory fandom
Kayleigh McEnany - Controversial political figure
Miranda Cosgrove - With the iCarly reboot doing well, and being a Paramount+ exclusive, she would be a great marketing tool like Bananas
Raven Symone - LGBT representation, a part of big shows like The View and That's So Raven
Tiffany Pollard - CBS has seen the millions of comments begging for her to be on the show. I think they would want to make this happen. Maybe a far stretch though.