While I did have fun hiding in plain sight as the killer there were several hints as to my identity, some more subtle than others...
Open Hint:
16 unsuspecting *players* will enter the Turney Manor in game like none other.
Everyone was assigned a card at the beginning telling them whether they were a PLAYER or KILLER. As the description of the group stated explicitly there would be 16 players, the killer naturally had to be someone else.
Investigation Hints:
In Episode 9, each location had evidence planted that had little to nothing to do with the actual case itself and instead pointed at my identity.
Stomach: What looks like a cross is carved into the skin, and the numbers, 54-52, are found carved under it
54-52 was a SCORE which was found UNDER a cross, a common symbol of CHRISTIANity
Christian + Under + Score = Christian_
Haybale: You find a 20 pack of rosaries underneath the hay
Rosaries=Christianity
20 is a number called a SCORE which was found UNDERneath the hay
Bookshelf: A picture of the chapel is found underneath a score of music
Chapel=Christianity which was found UNDERneath a SCORE of music