I was sooooo sad when she went home. She was one of the many great on this season. I honestly think that her elimination was rigged and she actually should have made it through but American idol did not want back to back female country winners. Anyways she should have won this season and if not then Chris daughtry or Katherine McPhee , but no the worst winner in American idol history won, Taylor hicks. This is why she is #1 because the winner was so horrible that season.
Btw if someone you like was not on this list don't neg because there are a lot of people I considered but these were the ones I believed were the most robbed.
#1