Not sure if she deserves last place but I'm not gonna argue the low ranking. There were just too many outside-game influences for her win to be more impressive.
I think that Amber played a decent game, she made the fake deal w/ Lex and Kathy to save herself and Shii Ann was even saying how Amber was the biggest threat, but nobody listened. I don't think she was a fantastic winner, but I don't think she's the worst winner
Also, she didn't have pregame alliances except maybe Jerri. Rob had all the alliances. They didn't even like each other at the beginning of all stars. They became close on the island.
Also, Lex was just one vote in the Jerri boot. It was Amber who saved herself with getting Kathy and Shii Ann on board.
karolusmagnus Well Amber was a great winner in my opinion, but her placement in this list isn't shocking. As for Rob being 27, is it because it took 4 times to win and because he was in the worst season with people who weren't bright? He dominated All Stars and Redemption Island, and is a great player. He may not be the best winner, but he certainly isn't #27. Inb4 Kim #1
He said he was good friends with both and they did not like eachother at all and it was only on the island when they became friends. Its more proof than your bs.
I'm just saying all the pre-game alliances was all Rob with Big Tom, Lex, Colby, etc. Rob was never tight with Amber pre-game. They started getting close on the island.
