I am using a points scale here of 0-20. 20 is the best player. HGs start out with 10 points and lose or gain according to my whim. Here they are, ranked in my capricious order of how good a player I think they are.
EXPLANATION OF SCORING
Everything should be obvious except that I add points rather than subtracting for being quiet, having a sheep mentality or being dumb. The reason for this is that the HG will be less of a target with any or all of these traits.
Kara - Pretty +5, Quiet +5, Sheep +3 = 20 (Can't go over 20)
Shane - Picks up subtle social clues +10, Dumb +2, = 20
Danielle - Sheep +3, Dumb +2 = 15
Frank - Overplay -10, Likeable +10, Good on his feet +3 = 13
Joe - Smart, Real Smart +10 - Obvious, Real Obvious -10 = 10
Ian - Somewhat delusional -4, Looks Unthreatening +5, Is Unthreatening -3 = 8
Jenn - Delusional -5, Sheep +3, 8
Will - Cracking already -5, not investigating anything -2, Sheep +3 = 6
Ashley - Delusional -5 = 5
JoJo - Secret Power Fetishist -6, Dumb as rock +2, Unruly sheep -2 = 4
Willie - Wow - 0
Comments
'pretty' as a reason to add points
..lol
also wtf "start out with 10 points", kara has +5 and +5 and +3 but is only at 13
..lol
also wtf "start out with 10 points", kara has +5 and +5 and +3 but is only at 13