In a way, he got screwed over by twists in both his seasons. (Outcast twist, Hidden Immunity Idol)
But he also got screwed over by ostracizing the minority. It's a good strategy that makes him a big player, but when it comes to twists, shifts et cetera, it makes him a prime candidate to get eliminated and I don't think he realized that coming into his second chance. He should have learned from his first time around that players like that are the first ones to get kicked off when twists happen, and he could have compensated for that to make it not happen this time...
In that sense, I'd say Savage didn't make the most of his second chance because he made the same mistake. And it makes me really sad because I think he could have won PI. But now he's just repeating his mistakes and being really bitter that it's not changing. I would hypothetically want to see him back, but I feel like it might be painful, also.
