Basically I proposed the idea of Survivor Legends following this format. 3 teams of 8. Each team consisting of 4 males and 4 females. The teams are:
1. Winners (Must be one of the 34 people who have claimed title of Sole Survivor)
2. Runner-Ups (Must have made it to the Final Tribal Council in a season but has never won)
3. All- Stars (Has never made it to the Final Tribal Council in any season)
Keep in mind they must have reason to be considered a Survivor Legend.
In six separate blogs I asked Tengaged to help create the cast by naming 4 males and 4 females for each. This is the cast made up by those who voted.
Winners Tribe Females- Parvati, Natalie A, Kim, and Sandra
Winners Tribe Males- Yul, Tony, Todd, and Richard
Runner-Ups Tribe Females- Amanda, Jaclyn, Courtney, and Carolyn
Runner-Ups Tribe Males- Russell, Ozzy, Colby, Spencer
All-Stars Tribe Females - Cirie, Andrea, Brenda, Wentworth
All-Stars Tribe Males - Rob C, Michael Y (S36), Malcom, Shane
Overall, I would be satisfied with this cast for a legends season although I do have some thoughts and notes.
1. Tina was next in line to be on the winners tribe.
2. As much as I think he is overrated, there is no way you could do a Legends season with out Rob M. Also Aras and Richard were actually tied... but come on you have to take Richard in that given its possible.
3. I love Carolyn, but in a Legends season I think Tasha would be a better fit.
4. Wentworth and Ciera actually tied, but I love Wentworth and she totally deserves title of Legend after her comeback in Second Chances. Ciera has been on a decline. My original choices included Kathy(S4,S8), Jerri, and Abi-Maria
5. The only clear winner for the Male All-Stars was Rob C, and oddly Michael. so I chose Malcom and Shane. Come on, Shane deserves an opportunity to play again. Although I'm not sure you can do a legends season without James or Rupert.
Anyways what do you all think of the cast? Any shocks?
Personally I think this would make for an interesting Season 40 cast... but I think we need a longer discussion the All-Star Males.
