Dan Gheesling
Season 10- 1st Place
Season 14- 2nd Place
How could you deny he's the best player ever? No one has ever made final 2 twice. Other than Dan. His lies and manipulation are masterpiece. He plays the ultimate game. Winning comps when he needs to. Lying when he needs to. Never getting into fights with other housemates. Orchestrating eviction after eviction. Dan is the ultimate player and I hope to see him back again.
Jordan Lloyd
Season 11- 1st Place
Season 13- 4th Place
I'm sure most of you were expecting Mike Boogie especially after my hint, but Mike isn't on this list. I'll probably be negged to no end for this one but it's my opinion so if you don't like it make your own. Jordan is just as good as Dr. Will, facts don't lie, she's placed just as good as he has. She has a much better social game then he does as well. Jordan proved in both her seasons that even without Jeff by her side she can do good! Her showmance has definitely helped her in her seasons. But she plays a great game, no one ever targets her until at least final 7. Call it what you want but I call that good game play.
Note: This list is based purely off of gameplay, NOT likeability. Some of the people on this list I disliked in their season, but there's no denying they played a good game.
Janelle Pierzina
Season 6- 3rd Place
Season 7- 3rd Place
Season 14- 12th Place
#3 a cruel but fitting placement for Janelle. In her first two seasons she made a few mistakes along the way but ultimately played phenomenal games both times. Winning competition after competition and proving to every one you can be pretty and be good at this game. She was hilarious and bitchy and you either loved her or hated her. She made it to final 3 both times and was just short of winning the final HoH, receiving 3rd two seasons in a row. In her most previous season, we saw a much more mature side of Janelle. Turns out maturity ruined her gameplay, her game was cut short and she couldn't make jury.
Note: This list is based purely off of gameplay, NOT likeability. Some of the people on this list I disliked in their season, but there's no denying they played a good game.
Dan Gheesling
Jordan Lloyd
Janelle Pierzina