COMMENTS:
Aquaria - I liked the shot, it felt editorial for me. I don't know if I can say this was a "bad setting" for the shoot because I actually can see this in a normal one. You look really feminine here, I was unable to see your man side which I see nothing wrong of. That dress was pretty good also.
Pietro - Well this was... basic. There's no modelling involved in this shot, I suppose. It felt like you had your friend took a picture of you in a beach, which does not necessarily mean a derelict scenery. This was the first challenge, so I won't put a heavy rock on you, but I would love to see you rock the photoshoot.
Valentina - I loveeeee this shot of you. It felt really high fashion in some kind of way, but you missed 50% of the challenge theme, a somehow messy scenery. I did not see it here. What you are wearing is really good, it boosted you up quite a bit. I did wish you think more of the setting.
Yoon Young - I think this is quite an impressive job, I actually expected you to do good for the first challenge. I was glad you delivered. This is a shot I would see in a magazine spread, and this is a job that probably would bring up discussion. I think you did quite a job.
Chanel - I am 50/50 with your shot. It felt really loose to my liking. It wasn't a bad shot, first of all, it actually is better than half I've seen already. But this shot is pretty lacking, but yeah it's your first challenge. I do hope you will do good in the next shoot though.
Victoria - Well... this was poorly made. I think this is something I would see any person would do though that will not make the cut for professional photographers. One thing though is that you actually looked quite different here.