The Callanish Standing Stones have become the site of an arena, The Arena of Rivalry. When a player is voted out, they will enter battle with their rival in a "Sword Battle" at Rivalry Arena.

The way a sword battle works is as follows: Beginning with the "Voted Out" player, rivals alternate between striking their opponent and defending attacks. Based on a first to 5 scoring system, a player must choose a section to either strike or defend. They have 3 choices in this matter: Head, Torso or Legs. The first player to successfully strike their rival 5 times wins the battle.

If the player "Voted Out" wins the battle, they will head to Redemption Island to await an opponent. If they lose this battle, however, they will be eliminated without ever going to Redemption Island.