Don't make me choose!!!
I think Second Chances 1 was generally more interesting from the get go while the main interest in SC2 came post merge (Chastain's longer than expected survival, the split votes, the downfall of many original tribe alliances), the fact that the final 3 is made up of 1 member from each of the 3 starting tribes is cool. It's hard to make a judgement without the results of the ftc and a close jury vote will definitely make this season better in my eyes. I think SC1 was just more explosive, the tribal councils more shocking and the rivalries more intense. The only thing I wish from SC1 is that Kpnna put up a fight at final tribal instead of really accepting second place.