Amanda Kimmel
Kelley Wentworth
Parvati Shallow
Sandra Diaz-Twine
Richard Hatch
Rob Cesternino
Todd Herzog
Yul Kwon
Timbira
Cirie Fields
Danni Boatwright
Kim Spradlin
Natalie Anderson
Brian Heidik
Rob Mariano
Russell Hantz
Tony Vlachos
I know some of these people are not considered to be 'Legends' by the general public or some of them may have only played once but they were the best cast that I could think of to fit the 16-people season format.