Here's the thing: I love the game you created. I think it's an interesting concept. It's a bit like that one where Paris Hilton wanted to find a new bff, only more realistic. lol.
The positives:
1) I loved your old hat. I thought it was a cool look.
2) You're a private eye.
3) You are one of the nicer black levels that I know.
4) You really wanted me to be in this game.
5) You are a fair judge/host, unlike Ms. Hilton.
6) Olimar is vastly underrated. (on a side note, I detest Mr. Gay n Watch).
The Neggies:
1) I miss your old hat. I thought it was cool.
2) I feel that Mario and Luigi are far more than just "fat plumbers".
That's it, Pat. I think the positives outweigh the neggies, but as you said, no one 100% likes somebody (obviously, I'm paraphrasing).