I am ranking them based on how much I like them and not on their games...as that is not really going to yield any positive results and is for the most part nitpicking and arbitrary
with that having said...
Rob Mariano
Now let it be said that I am a fan of Boston Rob...but this ranking is only encompassing a winners individual winning appearance. Anything any of them did outside of the season they won won't factor into their placement on this ranking...and with that said that lands Robert last on my list, despite the fact that I think he played a very good game (even if it was against braindead recruits who didn't know what they were doing).
Everything that I thought made him interesting in his first three seasons, his humor mostly, seemed forced and he was mostly confined to gamebotting in a horrible, consistently boring way on his way to an easy win with little obstacles thrust in his way.. Redemption Island is my least favorite season and this predictable win on Rob's part, which I found very boring and lacking anything that would make me enjoy it.. lands him this spot on the list..
I am ranking them based on how much I like them and not on their games...as that is not really going to yield any positive results and is for the most part nitpicking and arbitrary