For sure my answer is Elisabeth. Top 4 of her season, she was totally sweet and an amazing person. I love her sweetness, and she was so honest. I would like to see her again.
I never understood why Jeff is so "loved". He played 3 times, and he was jury... 0 times WTF
I also never understood why was Amber an "All stars". I definitely would give to Elisabeth a second chance. I know she doesn't want to come back but anyway...