I imagined a Survivor All Stars season : winners vs best players to never win.
My cast went like this, but I suppose there are many other options :
Winners
----------
Kim (Survivor One World)
Denise (Survivor Philippines)
Parvati (Survivor Micronesia)
Sandra (Survivor Pearl Islands and Survivor Heroes vs Villains)
Sophie (Survivor South Pacific)
Richard (Survivor Borneo)
Chris (Survivor Vanuatu)
Tom (Survivor Palau)
Yul (Survivor Cook Islands)
Tony (Survivor Cagayan)
Best Players to never win
--------------------------------
Natalie (Survivor Micronesia)
Brenda (Survivor Nicaragua and Survivor Caramoan)
Cirie (Survivor Exile Island, Survivor Micronesia and Survivor Heroes vs Villains)
Ciera (Survivor Blood vs Water)
Amanda (Survivor China, Survivor Micronesia and Survivor Heroes vs Villains)
Rob C (Survivor The Amazon and Survivor All Stars)
Malcolm (Survivor Philippines and Survivor Caramoan)
Spencer (Survivor Cagayan)
Hayden (Survivor Blood vs Water)
Stephen (Survivor Tocantins)
He was a shitty player.