from turney:
legend_of_link (kool)- Chicago deep dish pizza!
2. You made another safe dish I am honestly so disappointed right now. I dont think you understand that this is Top Chef: ALL STARS. If I wanted a Deep Dish Pizza, I would go to my local pizzeria.
Zed55- Gingery Sweet Potato Soup with an Orange Splash Cocktail
9. WOW. Just WOW. You knocked this out of the park. This is a HUGE turn around for you, and I am VERY impressed right now. Please keep this up. My only knock on the dish is the alcohol. You dont need to make us cocktails, especially when the soup can stand alone.
Jman96- Filet Mignon with bell Pepper Haystack and fresh Guacamole serfed with corn chips
8. This is a good dish! Im not WOWed by it, but the flavors are great you are trying to step out the box.
Tuninho- Honey Teriyaki Chicken with Ripe Pineapple Spears and Black and White Rice Balls
6. Okay here's the thing, the dish title sounds AMAZING but after reading the recipe, you can see its nothing unique. You made white rice then sprinkled black sesame seeds, you cut up pineapple, and you added honey to your teriyaki sauce. Dont think that a fancy title means that the dish is out of the box, because this dish was nothing special.
Realchance- STEAMED RED SNAPPER WITH CHANTERELLES AND ROCK SHRIMP OVER A BUTTERNUT SQUASH SAUCE
4.5. I dont see how this dish is representative of Season 1. Season 1 of Top Chef was filmed in San Francisco. If you explained how this dish was related to Season 1, then great, I will gladly raise this score, but Im confused. My hope is that you didnt just get a dish that a chef from Season 1 served and made that your representation. One dish cooked during the season does NOT mean it represents the whole season. Other than that, the dish was good, but since you didnt follow challenge rules, I cant give it a high score.