Clues:
A. The correct Island is located on the right side of the map (in a column to the right of the home island)
B. The correct island is labeled with an even number.
C. The correct island is the color green on the map.
D. The correct island is the color blue on the map.
E. The correct Island is located on the top half of the map (in a row above the home island)
F. The correct island is the color orange on the map.
G. The correct island is labeled with an odd number.
H. The correct Island is located on the bottom half of the map (in a row below the home island)
I. The correct island is the color red on the map.
J. The correct island is the color yellow on the map.
K. The correct Island is located on the left side of the map (in a column to the left of the home island)
L. The correct island is labeled with a prime number.
Chart:
https://imgur.com/a/noVds Directions were:
1 UP
8 LEFT (This direction had problems with multiple answers fitting the correct specifications)
4 DOWN
4 RIGHT