Welcome back! Thanks again to Becksta20 for taking the time to judge all of the submissions. I think we both were happy to see some lesser known Australian artists. Here are some opening remarks from Beck and our comments.
Thanks for bringing me a lot of new Australian music that I hadn’t heard before. I’ve enjoyed being a guest judge so thank you Tim for inviting me! There were a few great picks in there and I’m sure Tim will like some of them more than I did. Good luck everyone!
Happy Little Pill
T: I haven’t listened to Troye Sivan much since Blue Neighborhood. He honestly sounded like he was so bored the entire time and wasn’t bringing any real energy with his vocals. It just felt a bit flat for me.
B: I’m not usually a big fan of Troye Sivan and I don’t know why. I haven’t heard this song before but it was a nice song and I liked it more than his other songs.
Riptide
T: Fine song. I don’t love the vocals and have a hard time understanding him at times, but I appreciate the vibe.
B: Love this song! He has such a cute style and despite the film clip making me so confused when it first came out I always loved the song. Great pick!
Depreston
T: I liked the guitar and the overall instrumentation of the song. I was enjoying it for the first half, but it kind of dragged on towards the end.
B: I’ve not heard this song or artist before but I do like her style. She is very Australia and reminds me a bit of Missy Higgins who I love.
Timebomb
T: I really just wasn’t feeling this. I’d put this song in the category of songs that I’d probably enjoy while out dancing and drinking, but not necessarily in my day to day life. Like it has energy but isn’t particularly interesting.
B: Of all the Kylie songs…. I mean I love her but this is not her best by a long shot. Nevertheless, she is an icon and her music is always great.
Not the Same
T: I thought the song had strong vocals and a powerful instrumentation, but they didn’t really fit together for me. Kind of felt like they were competing against each other for most of the song.
B: Another song/artist I’ve never heard of so thanks for introducing him. He has a sweet voice and I liked this much more than a couple of others so far.
Smoke
T: Now this was great. I loved the vocals and how well it fit with the instrumentation. And I’ve probably said this many times by now, but I’m a sucker for horns, so I was hooked when the trumpets came in. Loved this!
B: This song is very meh for me. It could be catchy at times but it wasn’t keeping my attention.
24K
T: Nice beat. She kinda pops off in the verses. Definitely feeling this one.
B: Another one that is not my style. It’s a decent song but not something I’d listen to again.
Only High
T: Very ethereal and dreamy. This definitely would’ve hit back in college when I still indulged in certain activities. But I still liked the vibe and enjoyed the listening experience this gave.
B: To be honest – this is not really my usual style. I don’t listen to Geowulf so this was new for me and I actually didn’t mind it. I don’t know how it will go compared to others though after the first two submissions!
All Loved Up
T: Good song. I like how dynamic and engaging it is. And I think considering the guest judge, you probably made the right call with this pick haha
B: You are playing to the judges here because you know we love Amy Shark – and I’m definitely here for it! This is one of my favourite songs by her. Perfect selection!
Never Tear Us Apart
T: Wouldn’t say this is my favorite INXS song, but it’s enjoyable nonetheless.
B: This is a great Australian artist and song. I always love hearing this song because it is classic Aussie music. Nice pick.
Before revealing the next eliminated contestant, I just want to say that everyone brought their A-game this free choice round. Like I genuinely liked every song that was submitted, but only one can move on.
You are safe. Heavenlee, I'm sorry, but it's the end of the road. Noelle, you were a great contestant. Not only did you make it farther this time than in my first season, but you submitted one of my favorite new songs of the game so far with Mid Years. Thanks for much for playing <3
Round 9 Theme: Oldies but Goodies
I'm an old geezer who likes old music. So this round, send any song you like that is older than me (aka released before 1995) as well as your free choice song.
NOTE: This is gonna be a double so go for broke. Good luck!
Overall (average score):
All Loved Up (2)
Never Tear Us Apart (3.5)
Riptide (4.5)
Smoke (5)
Only High (5.5)
24K (6)
Depreston (6)
Timebomb (6.5)
Not the Same (8)
Happy Little Pill (8)
Tim’s Ranking:
Smoke
24K
All Loved Up
Only High
Never Tear Us Apart
Riptide
Depreston
Not the Same
Timebomb
Happy Little Pill
Beck’s Ranking:
All Loved Up
Never Tear Us Apart
Riptide
Timebomb
Depreston
Happy Little Pill
Only High
Not the Same
Smoke
24k
Free Choice Ranking
Naturally
The Fear
Vertigo (up for elimination)
1950
2 You
Beautiful and Bittersweet (up for elimination)
It Can’t Be That Hard
Dirrty
Billions
The Prayer
Yayyy I won! Hope you don’t think I was just playing to the judges, I love amy shark! I actually bought tickets to see her like 3-4 years ago but the show was a few hours away and we didn’t go😭😭
