I thought this would be a fun thing to try, just to see what kind of cast I can conjure up given that the last All Stars was literally 2 seasons ago. What I resulted in was a season I would actually quite enjoy, because of all of the history between the houseguests, I think it would lead to a lot of drama and a divided house taking shots at each other. This will definitely NOT be some people's cup of tea, though.
Now keep in mind, this is me trying to be realistic, not my absolute dream cast of 16. But with all of the beef (Paulie v. Josh, Haleigh and Fessy broke up, Brett got evicted by Kaycee, Paulie got evicted by Paul) and all of the genuine friendships (everyone in BB23, Josh/Kaycee/Fessy from The Challenge) and even family (Cody and Paulie), this would make a drama filled season. Now I know that production bringing back 6 people from one season is pretty unrealistic, but if there was a time for it it would be next season, because there are so many from last season who the fans are invested in and many of them would return. What are your thoughts? Who should be dropped from the cast? Who should be added?
Comments
oh now THIS would be funny
But honestly remove Sarah Beth and Claire and add Vanessa and Kaitlyn just for some extra unhidngeness
Eric (BB8, 5th)
Jason (BB3, 3rd)
John (BB17, 4th)
Kyland (BB23, 4th)
Paul (BB18, 2nd & BB19, 2nd)
Steve (BB17, 1st)
Victor (BB18, 5th)
Xavier (BB23, 1st)
For anyone curious, I put this cast through a BrantSteele with adjusted relationships/stats and these were the results:
Week 1:
HoH Winner: Derek
Have-Nots: Hannah, Josh, Paul, Paulie, Tiffany
Initial Nominees: Haleigh and Kaycee
PoV Winner: Kaycee
Veto Used: Yes on Kaycee
Replacement: Cody
Final Nominees: Haleigh and Cody
Evicted: Cody (7-6 Vote)
Week 2:
HoH Winner: Sarah Beth
Have-Nots: Brett, Faysal, Kaycee, Rachel, Xavier
Initial Nominees: Haleigh and Kaycee
PoV Winner: Sarah Beth
Veto Used: No
Final Nominees: Haleigh and Kaycee
Evicted: Kaycee (10-2 Vote)
Week 3:
HoH Winner: Rachel
Have-Nots: Danielle, Derek, Paul, Paulie
Initial Nominees: Haleigh and Paul
PoV Winner: Haleigh
Veto Used: Yes on Haleigh
Replacement: Derek
Final Nominees: Derek and Paul
Evicted: Paul (7-4 Vote)
Week 4:
HoH Winner: Xavier
Have-Nots: Brett, Haleigh, Josh
Initial Nominees: Haleigh and Josh
PoV Winner: Paulie
Veto Used: Yes on Haleigh
Replacement: Rachel
Final Nominees: Rachel and Josh
Evicted: Rachel (8-2 Vote)
Week 5:
HoH Winner: Danielle
Found Blocker Power: Haleigh
Found Disruptor Power: Brett
Found Replay Power: Hannah
Initial Nominees: Brett and Tiffany
Disruptor Power Used on Brett
Post-Disruptor Nominees: Paulie and Tiffany
PoV Winner: Paulie
Veto Used: Yes on Paulie
Replacement: Sarah Beth
Final Nominees: Sarah Beth and Tiffany
Evicted: Tiffany (6-3 Vote)
Week 6:
HoH Winner: Haleigh
Have-Nots: Hannah, Josh, Sarah Beth
Initial Nominees: Claire and Paulie
PoV Winner: Paulie
Veto Used: Yes on Paulie
Replacement: Sarah Beth
Final Nominees: Claire and Sarah Beth
Evicted: Claire (5*-4 Vote)
Week 7:
HoH Winner: Danielle
Have-Nots: Brett, Faysal, Paulie
Initial Nominees: Brett and Derek
PoV Winner: Derek
Blocker Power Used on Faysal
Veto Used: Yes on Derek
Replacement: Sarah Beth
Final Nominees: Brett and Sarah Beth
Evicted: Brett (6-1 Vote)
Week 8:
Replay Power Used on Danielle
HoH Winner: Paulie
Have-Nots: Josh, Xavier
Initial Nominees: Danielle and Josh
PoV Winner: Paulie
Veto Used: Yes on Danielle
Replacement: Hannah
Final Nominees: Hannah and Josh
Evicted: Josh (4-2 Vote)
Week 8 Triple Eviction: Part 1:
HoH Winner: Xavier
Initial Nominees: Danielle and Derek
PoV Winner: Danielle
Veto Used: Yes on Danielle
Replacement: Paulie
Final Nominees: Paulie and Derek
Evicted: Paulie (5-0 Vote)
Week 8 Triple Eviction: Part 2:
HoH Winner: Faysal
Initial Nominees: Sarah Beth and Xavier
PoV Winner: Derek
Veto Used: Yes on Xavier
Replacement: Danielle
Final Nominees: Sarah Beth and Danielle
Evicted: Danielle (3-1 Vote)
Week 9:
HoH Winner: Derek
Have-Nots: Haleigh
Initial Nominees: Faysal and Haleigh
PoV Winner: Hannah
Veto Used: Yes on Faysal
Replacement: Xavier
Final Nominees: Xavier and Haleigh
Evicted: Haleigh (2-1 Vote)
Week 10:
HoH Winner: Xavier
Initial Nominees: Derek and Faysal
PoV Winner: Faysal
Veto Used: Yes on Faysal
Replacement: Sarah Beth
Final Nominees: Derek and Sarah Beth
Evicted: Derek (2*-1 Vote)
Week 11:
HoH Winner: Faysal
Luxury Winner: Xavier
Initial Nominees: Sarah Beth and Xavier
PoV Winner: Faysal
Veto Used: No
Final Nominees: Sarah Beth and Xavier
Evicted: Xavier (1-0 Vote)
Final HoH:
Final HoH P1 Winner: Hannah
Final HoH P2 Winner: Sarah Beth
Final HoH P3 Winner: Sarah Beth
Evicted: Faysal (1-0 Vote)
Finale:
Winner: Sarah Beth
Runner-Up: Hannah
Favorite: Haleigh
Interesting that the simulation favored who my real life winner pick would be in this scenario. I think Sarah Beth would have a low threat level but would have many friends in the house.
But honestly remove Sarah Beth and Claire and add Vanessa and Kaitlyn just for some extra unhidngeness