In my eyes, two things make a legend. 1. Being a great character and 2. Being a great player. So, I've decided to figure out who the biggest Big Brother legend is by taking the two top confessional getters (ties broken by placement) and deciding who played better that episode, giving them a point. Whoever has the most points after I go through every season is the biggest Big Brother legend.
Because there are 23 seasons, I'll give you the top 23. Ties for most points are broken based on highest placement. If that's also a tie, that will be broken by next highest placement. If one player didn't play as many as the other so you can not break it by next highest placement, the one with more appearances will be placed higher. If they have tied and played the same amount of times, then the one with the earlier debut will be placed higher.
23. James Huling - (3 points)
I think this is a little high for James.
22. Memphis Garrett - (3 points)
This may be a bit high for Memphis.
21. Xavier Prather - (3 points)
This is about right for Xavier I think.
20. Josh Martinez - (3 points)
Not bad, one of the stand out characters on his season and the winner, this is about right.
19. Andy Herren - (3 points)
Probably about right.
18. Jun Song - (3 points)
Not a bad placement.
17. Ian Terry - (3 points)
Not bad.
16. Christie Murphy - (4 points)
Too high for Christie.
15. Jeff Schroeder - (4 points)
He might belong a little higher just due to his popularity at the time.
14. Alison Irwin - (4 points)
Maybe a little high.
13. Nicole Franzel - (4 points)
About the right spot for her, most days spent in the house.
12. Dani Briones - (5 points)
About right.
11. Danielle Reyes - (5 points)
Way too low.
10. Jackson Michie - (5 points)
Way too high.
9. Derrick Levasseur - (5 points)
Too low for Derrick.
8. Dick Donato - (5 points)
Probably a couple spots too low.
7. Rachel Reilly - (5 points)
About right.
6. Mike "Boogie" Malin - (5 points)
Based on post-show events, it may be too high now, but it wasn't before.
5. Will Kirby - (7 points)
Way too low.
4. Tyler Crispen - (8 points)
About right if a little high.
3. Cody Calafiore - (8 points)
Way too high.
2. Paul Abrahamian - (9 points)
They probably belong in the top 5, but 2 is a little high.
1. Dan Gheesling - (9 points)
Just right, I'm not sure he would be my first pick but I'm not mad at it.
