In my eyes, two things make a legend. 1. Being a great character and 2. Being a great player. So, I've decided to figure out who the biggest Survivor legend is by taking the two top confessional getters (ties broken by placement) and deciding who played better that episode, giving them a point. Whoever has the most points after I go through every season is the biggest Survivor legend.
Ep. 1
Keith Nale v. Josh Canfield
Josh voted against Baylor here, so Keith gets the point.
Ep. 2
Jeremy Collins v. Josh Canfield
Jeremy showed John the idol clue just for his loved one to be voted out, so Josh gets the point.
Ep. 3
Keith Nale v. Josh Canfield
Josh pushed for the Rocker blindside, so Josh gets the point.
Ep. 4
Jeremy Collins v. Drew Christy
Drew was voted out this episode, so Jeremy gets the point.
Ep. 5
Jon Misch v. Jeremy Collins
Jon was in a position of power this episode, so Jon gets the point.
Ep. 6
Natalie Anderson v. Jeremy Collins
Neither faced tribal council, but Natalie was shown the idol clue on Exile Island, so Natalie gets the point.
Ep. 7
Jeremy Collins v. Josh Canfield
Jeremy would have been blindsided if not for the Julie quit, so Josh gets the point.
Ep. 8
Jon Misch v. Josh Canfield
Josh was voted out this episode, so Jon gets the point.
Ep. 9
Jon Misch v. Jeremy Collins
Jeremy was voted out this episode, so Jon gets the point.
Ep. 10
Natalie Anderson v. Reed Kelly
Reed's plan fell apart while the plan to get Keith or Wes out worked, so Natalie gets the point.
Ep. 11
Jaclyn Schultz v. Jon Misch
Both were in pretty much the same spot, however, Jon found an idol, so I'll give Jon the point.
Ep. 12
Natalie Anderson v. Jon Misch
Jon was blindsided by Alec leaving, so Natalie gets the point.
Ep. 13
Baylor Wilson v. Jon Misch
Jon was voted out this episode, so Baylor gets the point.
Ep. 14
Natalie Anderson v. Keith Nale
Natalie won the game this episode, so she gets the point.
SEASON TOTALS
Natalie Anderson - 4 points
Jon Misch - 4 points
Josh Canfield - 3 points
Keith Nale - 1 point
Baylor Wilson - 1 point
Jeremy Collins - 1 point