In my eyes, two things make a legend. 1. Being a great character and 2. Being a great player. So, I've decided to figure out who the biggest Survivor legend is by taking the two top confessional getters (ties broken by placement) and deciding who played better that episode, giving them a point. Whoever has the most points after I go through every season is the biggest Survivor legend.
Ep. 1
Michael Skupin v. Zane Knight
Zane was voted out this episode, so Skupin gets this point.
Ep. 2
Jonathan Penner v. Roxy Morris
Roxy was voted out, so Penner gets this point.
Ep. 3
Jeff Kent v. Russell Swan
Russell was at the mercy of his tribe while Jeff was shown Penner's idol, so Jeff gets this point.
Ep. 4
Malcolm Freberg v. Russell Swan
Russell was voted out this episode, so Malcolm gets this point.
Ep. 5
Malcolm Freberg v. Jonathan Penner
Both had good episodes, but Malcolm ingratiated himself into Tandang really well, so Malcolm gets this point.
Ep. 6
Jonathan Penner v. Katie Hanson
Katie was voted out this episode, so Penner gets this point.
Ep. 7
Lisa Whelchel v. Jonathan Penner
Penner played his idol correctly but was also on the wrong side of the vote, so Lisa gets the point.
Ep. 8
Malcolm Freberg v. Pete Yurkowski
Malcolm was on the wrong side of the vote, so Pete gets the point.
Ep. 9
Lisa Whelchel v. Jonathan Penner
Lisa was on the wrong side of the vote, so Penner gets the point.
Ep. 10
Michael Skupin v. Malcolm Freberg
Malcolm was at Skupin's mercy as he thought about flipping and sending him out, so Skupin gets the point.
Ep. 11
Lisa Whelchel v. Abi-Maria Gomes
Abi was on the wrong side of the vote, so Lisa gets the point.
Ep. 12
Lisa Whelchel v. Malcolm Freberg
Malcolm needed immunity to stay safe, so Lisa gets the point.
Ep. 13
Lisa Whelchel v. Malcolm Freberg
Both voted correctly, but Malcolm won immunity, so Malcolm gets the point.
Ep. 14
Michael Skupin v. Lisa Whelchel
Both lost the game this episode and received the same number of jury votes, but Skupin was the one to win immunity to send Malcolm out, so Skupin gets the point.
SEASON TOTALS
Michael Skupin - 3 points
Lisa Whelchel - 3 points
Malcolm Freberg - 3 points
Jonathan Penner - 3 points
Pete Yurkowski - 1 point
Jeff Kent - 1 point
