In my eyes, two things make a legend. 1. Being a great character and 2. Being a great player. So, I've decided to figure out who the biggest Survivor legend is by taking the two top confessional getters (ties broken by placement) and deciding who played better that episode, giving them a point. Whoever has the most points after I go through every season is the biggest Survivor legend.
Ep. 1
Sabrina Thompson v. Alicia Rosa
Alicia got into a fight with Christina, so Sabrina gets the point.
Ep. 2
Sabrina Thompson v. Nina Acosta
Nina was voted out this episode, so Sabrina gets the point.
Ep. 3
Chelsea Meissner v. Matt Quinlan
Matt was voted out this episode, so Chelsea gets the point.
Ep. 4
Sabrina Thompson v. Bill Posley
Bill was voted out this episode, so Sabrina gets the point.
Ep. 5
Alicia Rosa v. Colton Cumbie
Both were on the right side of the vote, but Colton was the one who wanted to take out Monica, so Colton gets the point.
Ep. 6
Alicia Rosa v. Colton Cumbie
Colton was evacuated this episode, so Alicia gets the point.
Ep. 7
Chelsea Meissner v. Troyzan Robertson
Chelsea got into a tiff with Tarzan, while Troyzan found an idol and won immunity, so Troyzan gets the point.
Ep. 8
Kim Spradlin v. Jay Byars
Kim tricked Troyzan into voting against Michael, so Kim gets the point.
Ep. 9
Troyzan Robertson v. Jay Byars
Jay was voted out this episode, so Troyzan gets the point.
Ep. 10
Chelsea Meissner v. Troyzan Robertson
Troyzan voted incorrectly, so Chelsea gets the point.
Ep. 11
Kim Spradlin v. Troyzan Robertson
Troyzan was voted out this episode, so Kim gets the point.
Ep. 12
Kim Spradlin v. Chelsea Meissner
Both were in a power position this episode, but we saw Kim get taken on the reward and win immunity, so Kim gets the point.
Ep. 13
Kim Spradlin v. Alicia Rosa
Both were in a power position, but Kim told Chelsea that she might vote her out while Alicia won immunity, so Alicia gets the point.
Ep. 14
Kim Spradlin v. Christina Cha
Kim won the game this episode, so she gets the point.