The rules are: you have to had played multiple times to be considered. I will rank all of their games, and the highest average position will result in you moving onto the next round. (Eventually, I want to figure out who the best ever is using this metric.)
Our contenders:
Tina Wesson
Colby Donaldson
Amber Brkich
Jerri Manthey
Alicia Calaway
Jeff Varner
Michael Skupin
Kimmi Kappenberg
1. Tina's AO game
2. Amber's AS game
3. Jerri's HvV game
4. Colby's AO game
5. Tina's BvW game
6. Michael's Philippines game
7. Colby's HvV game
8. Kimmi's SC game
9. Amber's AO game
10. Alicia's AO game
11. Jeff's AO game
12. Michael's AO game
13. Jerri's AO game
14. Alicia's AS game
15. Jeff's SC game
16. Jerri's AS game
17. Colby's AS game
18. Amber's WaW game
19. Kimmi's AO game
20. Tina's AS game
21. Jeff's GC game
Borneo: Richard Hatch
AO: Tina Wesson
Africa:
Marquesas:
Thailand:
The Amazon:
Pearl Islands:
All Stars:
Vanuatu:
Palau:
Guatemala:
Panama:
Cook Islands:
Fiji:
China:
Micronesia:
Gabon:
Tocantins:
Samoa:
Heroes vs. Villains:
Nicaragua:
Redemption Island:
South Pacific:
One World:
Philippines:
Caramoan:
Blood vs. Water:
Cagayan:
San Juan del Sur:
Worlds Apart:
Cambodia:
Kaoh Rong:
Millennials vs. Gen X:
Game Changers:
Heroes vs. Healers vs. Hustlers:
Ghost Island:
David vs. Goliath:
Edge of Extinction:
Island of the Idols:
Winners at War:
As it should be