The rules are: you have to had played multiple times to be considered. I will rank all of their games, and the highest average position will result in you moving onto the next round. (Eventually, I want to figure out who the best ever is using this metric.)
Our contenders:
Richard Hatch
Kelly Wiglesworth
Rudy Boesch
Sue Hawk
Gervase Peterson
Jenna Lewis
1. Richard's Borneo game
2. Jenna's All Stars game
3. Kelly's Borneo game
4. Sue's Borneo game
5. Rudy's Borneo game
6. Gervase's Blood vs. Water game
7. Gervase's Borneo game
8. Jenna's Borneo game
9. Richard's All Stars game
10. Kelly's Cambodia game
11. Rudy's All Stars game
12. Sue's All Stars game
Since Richard and Jenna tied, the tiebreaker will be who had the better first game. And, Richard's Borneo game beats Jenna's Borneo game, so Richard Hatch will be advancing into the next round.
Some of the ranking may be controversial given what happened between Rich and Sue in All Stars, and of course I empathize and am on Sue's side completely, however I tried to look at who's gameplay was more impressive with as little bias as possible.