This site uses cookies. If you continue to browse the site, we shall assume that you accept the use of cookies.
Big Brother and online Hunger games.

Comment 2 Big Brother players

May 11, 2021 by survivornerd
And I’ll tell you which I think is a better player

#casting

Comments

Janelle Da'Vonne
Sent by Mrkk,May 11, 2021
Will Kirby Dan Gheesling
Sent by DBonee,May 11, 2021
David (BB21) Victoria (BB16)
Sent by NanoNerd,May 11, 2021
Meg Maley and Jessica Milagros
Sent by Tommy123,May 11, 2021
Mrkk Janelle > Da'Vonne

I definitely do not think Da'Vonne is a great BB player, and that shows from her poor outing over all of her seasons (3 seasons and she's never reached a single-digit placement). Janelle's last 2 outings in BB14 and BB22 were obviously pretty bad, but she did make F3 in BB6 & 7. I don't know if she stood a real chance at winning BB6 just because the Friendship would vote for one of their own no matter what, but she definitely almost won BB7. I think Janelle is just better at knowing who to tell information to, while Da'Vonne lets a lot of information out to the wrong people.
Sent by survivornerd,May 12, 2021
DBonee Will Kirby < Dan Gheesling

The great debate, Lebron vs. MJ. I have to go with Dan, though. I think these two are possibly the top 2 best to ever do it, although there is an argument for Derrick and whoever else. Both were masters at controlling how other people perceived them, and that allowed them to advance to the end. I think Dan stood no chance to win 14 once Boogie walked out the door, while Will had a shot at winning 7, but ironically I think Dan showcased his abilities while I think Will got sloppy and wanted too badly to show how he was outwitting people, and it came back to bite him in the ass. I also think Dan is better during jury questioning, you could argue that he isn't because of how he lost 14, but no coach was ever going to win 14 unless they sat next to each other. Will's BB2 jury questioning reflects one of the bigger flaws in his game, he always wants to be seen as the smart guy who dunked on everyone else. Which of course, results in Will being the better character.
Sent by survivornerd,May 12, 2021
NanoNerd Since you included the season numbers, I'll compare those specific games.

David (BB21) > Victoria (BB16)

Obviously, both pretty awful games. I do think that if Victoria reaches the end, no matter what, she does not win. I know the Detonators made a pact to vote for Victoria if one of them took her to the end, but I absolutely do not buy that at all. I think if David reaches the end, there's at least a story there where he was a rookie among all these All Stars. Realistically, I don't think either stood that much of a shot, and although David shot himself in the foot multiple times this season, I lean towards him here.
Sent by survivornerd,May 12, 2021
Tommy123 Meg Maley > Jessica Milagros

I just don't think Jessica is going to be in the loop in a lot of seasons she plays in, where I could see Meg getting into a good position and riding that to the end more often. It is really hard to see a path where Jessica ever wins Big Brother in my opinion, so I have to go Meg here.
Sent by survivornerd,May 12, 2021

Leave a comment