This site uses cookies. If you continue to browse the site, we shall assume that you accept the use of cookies.
Big Brother and online Hunger games.

Comment 2 Survivor Players

May 11, 2021 by survivornerd
And I'll tell you which I think is a better player

#survivor

Comments

me and peace123

We are both survivor players in our minds if that counts, but this will determine a lot, who you decide right here right now will decide our fate.
Sent by EricCabello,May 11, 2021
Tony and Sandra
Sent by woeisme,May 11, 2021
Kass and Noura
Sent by BarbraStreisand,May 11, 2021
ericcabello you
Sent by survivornerd,May 11, 2021
Parvati and russell
Sent by Bertinho,May 11, 2021
Cirie and Domenick
Sent by woeisme,May 11, 2021
woeisme Tony > Sandra

I don't want to discount Sandra's accomplishments, but if we put Tony and Sandra into 100 seasons, Tony would win, I think, significantly more than Sandra. Especially in the new school era of play, Sandra I think will have an extremely hard time, where as I think Tony could win in an old school season. Also, Tony would never make the play of giving away an idol like Sandra did in S40. That being said, I think Sandra is a great player, but I also think that she can not overcome adversity the way Tony can in the game.
Sent by survivornerd,May 11, 2021
survivornerd you are so loyal! I love that!
Sent by EricCabello,May 11, 2021
spencer tasha
Sent by NotNicky333,May 11, 2021
Kim Sarah
Sent by hwest14,May 11, 2021
Shii Ann Huang & Coby Archa
Sent by NewNightmare7,May 11, 2021
BarbraStreisand Kass > Noura

Although the jury hated her in Cagayan, and Noura was kind of a non-option at the end but in general liked by the jury, I have a hard time seeing Noura doing any better than her performance in Island of the Idols, where as I think you could see seasons in which Kass reaches the end and the jury rewards her gameplay.
Sent by survivornerd,May 11, 2021
Malcolm and Spencer
Sent by woeisme,May 11, 2021
Bertinho Parvati > Russell

Although I think Russell is the most underrated player on tengaged & reddit (and the most overrated player on Facebook), Parvati is definitely a better player. Both are great at overcoming adversity, and although no one is super thrilled to vote Parvati if she hits the end, there will always be juries that would vote AGAINST Russell. Parvati is also usually a safe bet to reach the end game, where I think we'd see Russell get knocked out pre-merge much more often.
Sent by survivornerd,May 11, 2021
woeisme Cirie > Domenick

I think two of the best to never win, but I think Cirie is definitely THE best to never win. She is the only person to be a real jury threat and reach the endgame THREE times. And all three of those times were due to twists in one way or the other. Between Terry's idol, the F2 instead of F3, and advantage-geddon, and although these are eliminations that I think she is responsible for (besides Micro, although with all the med evacs maybe she should have prepared for it better), I think that they are rare occurences. Although I think that if you pick Domenick here that is also valid, because he will have a much better chance at winning clutch immunities, and he's much better when it comes to advantage management.
Sent by survivornerd,May 11, 2021
NotNicky333 Spencer > Tasha

Both have similar track records, but I think that Spencer plays much harder, and although he didn't get any votes in Cambodia, you could see scenarios where some jurors would vote for that gameplay. Tasha I think only wins if she's put into an underdog situation like Cagayan and wins out to the end, I know that she annoyed people in Cambodia with her talk about how God wants her to win or whatever. When both are put into troublesome situations, I'd have much more trust in Spencer to get out of it.
Sent by survivornerd,May 11, 2021
hwest14 Kim < Sarah

This is really hard. I think that Kim 1.0 was obviously MILES above Sarah 1.0, but if we go off of who they are now, I think Sarah is the better player. Kim in WaW did not overly impress me, while Sarah did, she is lauded for her advantage management and her strategy, but WaW also showed that she has a killer social game as well, making several bonds with the likes of people like Sophie and Ben, and I think that Tony has Sarah to thank for some of his win, because she helped to build the foundation of that alliance. Kim has I think the best win in Survivor history though.
Sent by survivornerd,May 11, 2021
NewNightmare7 Shii Ann Huang < Coby Archa

I have a really hard time remembering Coby's game, but I know he was at least one of the ones angling to get rid of Tom which would have been a good move. Shii Ann has never had a great Survivor outing, I know she was screwed over by the fake merge in 5, but she was never winning that game anyways, let's face it. We also see her get into more conflicts than I remember Coby getting into, there were definitely people who detested Shii Ann. Although, I do love Shii Ann as a character.
Sent by survivornerd,May 11, 2021
woeisme Malcolm < Spencer

This is another close one, but for me, in the game where Malcolm came closest to winning, he was surrounded by a lot of bad players, whereas in the 2 games Spencer came close to winning, he was surrounded by, in my opinion, a lot of good players. Malcolm's game in Caramoan was piss poor, he had no feel for the timing of when he should have made a move, and when he made his "big move" with his two idols, he took out Phillip, who probably stood no chance of winning anyways.
Sent by survivornerd,May 11, 2021
Although I will say, Malcolm wins every final tribal he sits at, Spencer does not.
Sent by survivornerd,May 11, 2021
Thanks for these!
I have 2 more if you'd like

Amanda and Aubry

Todd and Cochran
Sent by woeisme,May 11, 2021
woeisme Aubry > Amanda

I actually went back and forth on this, as I think that Amanda's three games trump Aubry's bottom 2 games, IDK wtf Aubry's EoE game was, and her Game Changers appearance was also lackluster. However, in the two final 3s Amanda has been in, she was the bottom jury threat in all three (although she was somewhat close to Parvati.) Meanwhile, Aubry was the top jury threat besides Michele, who went on an immunity run and became impossible to vote out. Aubry also had to deal with two of her closest allies getting evaced, and in spite of that, ran that game. So, I think sometimes we will see Aubry taper out in the pre-merge, and most of the time Amanda will last longer than her, but I think Aubry wins more often.
Sent by survivornerd,May 11, 2021
woeisme Todd > Cochran

Both are very good players, but I think that I would trust Todd to win more times out of 100 than Cochran. We see Cochran's SP game, where I think he was in a tough spot to win regardless, but him flipping was absolutely not the right move for his game. He also just failed to make important bonds with people that game, where as I think Todd will always have friends in a Survivor season. And when we take Cochran's game in Caramoan into account, although it was very impressive, and he did everything right, he was put into a very, very good position from the jump. Both are well spoken at tribal council, but Todd put on perhaps one of the best performances ever in China.
Sent by survivornerd,May 11, 2021
ericcabello you.
Sent by peace123,May 11, 2021
peace123 sorry you heard it here first
Sent by EricCabello,May 11, 2021

Leave a comment