Putting the cast up against each other and picking out which made better TV - the further you went, the more you're worth.
1 point - Pat Cusack < Amber Mariano
2 points - Jessica Peet < Danni Boatwright
3 points - Jeremy Crawford < Ethan Zohn
4 points - Bi Nguyen < Rob Mariano
5 points - Natalia Azoqa < Parvati Shallow
6 points - Natalie Cole > Sandra Diaz-Twine
7 points - Lyrsa Torres < Yul Kwon
8 points - Elizabeth Olson < Wendell Holland
9 points - John Hennigan < Adam Klein
10 points - Dan Rengering < Tyson Apostol
11 points - Alec Merlino > Sophie Clarke
12 points - Carl Boudreaux > Kim Spradlin-Wolfe
13 points - Gabby Pascuzzi < Jeremy Collins
14 points - Christian Hubicki > Nick Wilson
15 points - Davie Rickenbacker > Denise Stapley
16 points - Alison Raybould > Ben Driebergen
17 points - Kara Kay < Sarah Lacina
18 points - Angelina Keeley > Michele Fitzgerald
19 points - Mike White > Natalie Anderson
20 points - Nick Wilson < Tony Vlachos
By a score of 111-99, the superior cast moving onto the top 10 is...
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
David vs. Goliath!
TOP 10
David vs. Goliath
Heroes vs. Healers vs. Hustlers/Millennials vs. Gen X
Kaoh Rong/San Juan del Sur
Blood vs. Water/Philippines
South Pacific/Nicaragua
Heroes vs. Villains/Tocantins
Micronesia/Cook Islands
Panama/Vanuatu
Pearl Islands/Amazon
Africa/Borneo
Where do we disagree? Let's discuss! I think it's important to mention here that I made these choices based on how they were depicted on THESE PARTICULAR SEASONS. Obviously if it was based on all time appearances, Sophie and Kim beat Alec and Carl. Natalie also wipes the floor with Mike in that case.