Putting the cast up against each other and picking out which made better TV - the further you went, the more you're worth.
1 point - Sonja Christopher > Debb Eaton
2 points - BB Andersen > Kel Gleason
3 points - Stacey Stillman < Maralyn Hershey
4 points - Ramona Gray > Mitchell Olsen
5 points - Dirk Been < Kimmi Kappenberg
6 points - Joel Klug < Michael Skupin
7 points - Gretchen Cordy > Jeff Varner
8 points - Greg Buis > Alicia Calaway
9 points - Jenna Lewis < Jerri Manthey
10 points - Gervase Peterson > Nick Brown
11 points - Colleen Haskell > Amber Brkich
12 points - Sean Kenniff > Rodger Bingham
13 points - Susan Hawk > Elisabeth Filarski
14 points - Rudy Boesch > Keith Famie
15 points - Kelly Wiglesworth < Colby Donaldson
16 points - Richard Hatch > Tina Wesson
By a score of 98-38, the superior cast moving onto the top 20 is...
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Borneo!
TOP 10
Winners at War/David vs. Goliath
Heroes vs. Healers vs. Hustlers/Millennials vs. Gen X
Kaoh Rong/San Juan del Sur
Blood vs. Water/Philippines
South Pacific/Nicaragua
Heroes vs. Villains/Tocantins
Micronesia/Cook Islands
Panama/Vanuatu
Pearl Islands/Amazon
Africa/Borneo
Where do we disagree? Let's discuss! I think it's important to mention here that I made these choices based on how they were depicted on THESE PARTICULAR SEASONS. Obviously if it was based on who they are as people, Michael Skupin would not beat Joel.
