Putting the cast up against each other and picking out which made better TV - the further you went, the more you're worth.
Carolyn and Will tied for 2nd, but for the sake of the format, I just put whomever was listed directly under Mike in the Wikipedia as 2nd, and the other as 3rd.\
1 point - So Kim > Nadiya Anderson
2 points - Vince Sly > Val Collins
3 points - Nina Poersch < John Rocker
4 points - Lindsey Cascaddan < Drew Christy
5 points - Max Dawson > Kelley Wentworth
6 points - Joaquin Souerbielle < Dale Wentworth
7 points - Kelly Remington > Julie McGee
8 points - Hali Ford < Josh Canfield
9 points - Joe Anglim < Jeremy Collins
10 points - Jenn Brown > Wes Nale
11 points - Shirin Oskooi < Reed Kelly
12 points - Tyler Fredrickson > Alec Christy
13 points - Dan Foley > Jon Misch
14 points - Sierra Dawn Thomas < Baylor Wilson
15 points - Rodney Lavoie < Keith Nale
16 points - Will Sims < Missy Payne
17 points - Carolyn Rivera > Jaclyn Schultz
18 points - Mike Holloway < Natalie Anderson
By a score of 104-67, the superior cast moving onto the top 20 is...
.
.
.
.
.
.
San Juan del Sur!
TOP 20
Winners at War
David vs. Goliath
Heroes vs. Healers vs. Hustlers
Millennials vs. Gen X
Kaoh Rong
San Juan del Sur
Cagayan/BvW
FvF2/Philippines
OW/SP
RI/Nicaragua
HvV/Samoa
Tocantins/Gabon
FvF/China
Fiji/CI
EI/Guatemala
Palau/Vanuatu
AS/PI
Amazon/Thailand
Marquesas/Africa
AO/Borneo