What I'm doing is going based off of number of wins first: the more wins you have, obviously the better player you are in general. TIER 1 is who has won twice. TIER 2 is who has won and has gotten within 3 eliminations of the finals (final 5 in F2 seasons, final 6 in F3 seasons). TIER 3 is people who have won once, and TIER 4 is people who have gotten within 3 eliminations twice. You have to atleast played twice, because one is too small of a sample size to go off of.
CONTENDERS
Richard Hatch - won once
Tina Wesson - won once, came within 3 elims
Colby Donaldson - came within 3 elims 2x
Ethan Zohn - won once
Tom Buchanan - came within 3 elims 2x
Jenna Morasca - won once
Amber Mariano - won once
Rob Mariano - won once, came within 3 elims
Rupert Boneham - came within 3 elims 2x
Tom Westman - won once
Danni Boatwright - won once
Aras Baskauskas - won once
Cirie Fields - came within 3 elims 3x
Yul Kwon - won once
Ozzy Lusth - came within 3 elims 2x
Parvati Shallow - won once, came within 3 elims 2x
Amanda Kimmel - came within 3 elims 2x
Erik Reichenbach - came within 3 elims 2x
JT Thomas - won once
Coach Wade - came within 3 elims 2x
Russell Hantz - came within 3 elims 2x
Sophie Clarke - won once
Kim Spradlin - won once
Denise Stapley - won once, came within 3 elims
John Cochran - won once
Tyson Apostol - won once
Spencer Bledsoe - came within 3 elims 2x
Natalie Anderson - won once, came within 3 elims 1x
Keith Nale - came within 3 elims 2x
Jeremy Collins - won once
Michele Fitzgerald - won once came within 3 elims 1x
Aubry Bracco - came within 3 elims 2x
Tai Trang - came within 3 elims 2x
Adam Klein - won once
Sarah Lacina - won once, came within 3 elims 1x
Ben Driebergen - won once, came within 3 elims 1x
Wendell Holland - won once
Nick Wilson - won once
TIER 1 - won twice
1. Tony Vlachos
2. Sandra Diaz-Twine
TIER 2 - won once, came within 3 elims
3. Parvati Shallow
4. Sarah Lacina
5. Tina Wesson
6. Natalie Anderson
7. Rob Mariano
8. Michele Fitzgerald
9. Denise Stapley
10. Ben Driebergen
