Splitting up the episodes into 6 sections, whomever has the most confessionals per that section earns a spot on my DVD.
Episodes 1-3
John Cody and Brad Culpepper tie with 16 confessionals, and they also tie for most total confessionals, so we'll take it episode by episode.
Episode 1 - Brad
Episode 2 - John
Episode 3 - John
Episode 4 - Brad
Episode 5 - tie
Episode 6 - tie
Episode 7 - tie
Episode 8 - John
With 3 points over Brad's 2, John gets this spot on the DVD.
Episodes 4-6
Tyson gets this spot with 10 confessionals.
Episodes 7-8
Vytas gets this spot with 9 confessionals.
Episodes 9-10
Despite getting 0 confessionals in episode 9, Ciera gets this spot with 11 confessionals.
Episodes 11-12
Hayden gets this spot with 12 confessionals.
Episodes 13-14
Monica Culpepper wins the last spot with 13 confessionals.
MY DVD:
John Cody
Vytas Baskauskas
Hayden Moss
Ciera Eastin
Monica Culpepper
Tyson Apostol
ACTUAL DVD:
Candice Cody
Vytas Baskauskas
Hayden Moss
Ciera Eastin
Tina Wesson
Tyson Apostol
Which DVD is better? It's Tina/Candice or John/Monica. I think that although Tina came close to winning, Monica was a much bigger and more memorable character, and Candice and John both spent a lot of time on Redemption Island, but I feel like John got more screen-time, Candice didn't have much of an impact on the game. My DVD is better.