Splitting up the episodes into 6 sections, whomever has the most confessionals per that section earns a spot on my DVD.
Episodes 1-3
Jerri is a mile ahead of everyone with 21 confessionals.
Episodes 4-6
Colby earns his spot with 15 confessionals.
Episodes 7-8
Elisabeth has 14 here and earns a spot on the DVD.
Episodes 9-10
Tina and Keith tie here with 9. To break the tie we see who has the most TOTAL confessionals, and by just 1 confessional, that is Keith.
Episodes 11-12
Tina earns this with 11 confessionals.
Episodes 13-14
Since the final 4 has already gotten onto the DVD, we will pick out whoever has the most TOTAL confessionals that hasn't already been picked. However, Jeff and Rodger tie with 35. So we will go episode by episode and reward a point for whoever received more confessionals.
Ep. 1 - Jeff
Ep. 2 - Jeff
Ep. 3 - Jeff
Ep. 4 - Rodger
Ep. 5 - Jeff
Ep. 6 - Jeff
Ep. 7 - Jeff
Ep. 8 - Rodger
Ep. 9 - tie
Ep. 10 - Rodger
Ep. 11 - Rodger
Ep. 12 - Rodger
Ep. 13 - tie
Ep. 14 - tie
By only one episode, Jeff Varner earns the last spot on the DVD.
My DVD:
Jeff Varner
Jerri Manthey
Elisabeth Filarski
Keith Famie
Colby Donaldson
Tina Wesson
The actual DVD:
Alicia Calaway
Jerri Manthey
Rodger Bingham
Elisabeth Filarski
Colby Donaldson
Tina Wesson
Who's is better? So the only differences is one has Alicia/Rodger, the other has Jeff/Keith. This is actually kind of a tough call to me. In my eyes, Jeff had a much bigger impact on the season than Alicia did, and Keith had a bigger impact than Rodger, yet Rodger was much more loveable than Keith. Tell me what you guys think, but I think for this round my DVD had a better representation of the season.
